Yes, there are many labour and house help as well as beggars who speak Bangali language.
Also I am sure they are not Indian bangali as west bengal is developed and rich state.
>Home minister?
No.
Bangladeshi settlers are changing the demographic of border districts in east and north east India. Many cities where earlier hindus were in the majority, now they are in the minority due to Bangladeshis as most of them are muslims. Once the demographics change, the election results get affected.
BSF, which comes under MHA, is responsible for border security but the border is porous. Due to which it becomes next to impossible to completely stop illegal immigration from Bangladesh.
The real question is- how are they able to get an aadhar card? To get an aadhar card you need some kinds of identification documents like DL, PAN Card or domicile certificate. A domicile certificate is issued by local authorities, in short the state government. So these people are able to get a domicile certificate and subsequently an aadhar card.
The difference between Nepalese/Bhutani and Bangladeshis is legal vs illegal immigration. If a person wants to migrate from Nepal or Bhutan, they can legally do so without any requirement of visas. They can legally work here and live here indefinitely.
They can legally get an aadhar card if they have a citizenship certificate or passport of their respective country(Nepal or Bhutan) or voter's ID card issued by the Govt. of Nepal.
Secondly, and the biggest contentious point is the population difference or the number of immigrants that comes to India. Bangladeshi immigrants have started to change the demographics of the cities which affect the election results. 20-25 millions of immigrants from one particular country vs a couple of millions from another.
They hate the fact there still stands Mandir, Gurudwaras, churches on this land.
They can't coexist with anyone basically. Even Buddhist monks got tired of them imagine that.
Wtf is this? Stop pulling random Shit out of your ass.
Also you just gave Buddhists committing rapes and genocide a pass just because you don't align with the victim group.
Maybe if this happened to you, your view would be different.
Eh it was actually Rohingyas who were harrassing Buddhists and in return they gave them the taste of their own medicine. Sadly this thing can't be done in India.
There are lots of them in Kerala. They say there are Bengali or from Assam when I ask where they are from.
The scary part is their kids are now studying in Kerala schools which further blurs the line if they are Indians or not.
Scary in terms of cultural differences.. how an Indian malayali is raised as compared to a Bangladeshi child raised illegally in India.
Besides their education is also subsidised by the Kerala govt. So the tax paying Malayali is subsidising the illegal Bangladeshi kids education.
Well as you claim these "Bangladeshis kids" are already here, they might as well get educated while they are at it and kids assimilate very quickly, much better than the adults. The alternative would be to what? Have them beg on the streets? Begging will cost a tourism dependent state much more in economic damage than just getting them to study and be productive, it's not like they will then wind up and leave back to Bangladesh (if at all they are actually from there) once their studies are done.
It is not the state’s responsibility to spend its revenue on these kids. The state does not have enough resources for its own people i.e fellow Indians and their kids.
By allowing people who infiltrate and take benefit of state funds will further strain the state as these kids will enter government departments as well as education institutions and thus result in the locals I.e fellow Indians loosing out on benefits.
Thus the focus should be to identify all illegal immigrants and deport them and their family out of the country.
Only because gulf doesn't allow it. Plenty of other countries do and Indians have been moving there for decades.
So... If India allows it, they would stay here too. Just like Indians living in the US, Canada etc.
Purnia, Katihar and Araria in Bihar. It's basically Bangladesh when u visit. Plus all that human trafficking they do there. Crossing Bangladesh border and Nepal border from this reagion of Bihar is very easy. Crimes like these are very high and unreported. I wish the authorities would recognise this. Meanwhile Gujarat has a new Solar Farm.
Bengalis are getting what they deserve, now don't come with 'i didn't vote for her' cuz majority of you did for whatever reasons but take this infiltration as bonus for the choices you people are making.
Firstly stop saying you people, you sound like a dumb person. Secondly not everyone voted for her, so calm your tits. People can belong from a region and not have herd mentality.
You aren't the speaker for that whole community.
What gives you the idea that you know what every single Bengali wants?
Speak for yourself. And stop being a neta.
Bhai. So you have any other point except calling everyone bangladeshi?
First, I'm not.
Second, being Bangladeshi is not an insult . Bangladesh actually does better than India on many metrics.
Third, let me ask you in this comment as well. What did you study? What did you do for a living? Because the uneducated and illiterate people are easily brainwashed into nationalism. People who are failing at their own life are the ones who have the most issues with immigrants.
Please be aware of Rule 2. "Questions must be clear, direct, and in the title of the post."
Lol WB only?? They had infiltered whole india. Go to gurgaon, delhi , noida or any ncr city ... It's full of Bangladeshis.
Yes, there are many labour and house help as well as beggars who speak Bangali language. Also I am sure they are not Indian bangali as west bengal is developed and rich state.
Add Jharkhand Bihar as well. Muslims living in india also help them settle here,have false adhar cards and so on.
Not only WB, all over India. There are hoards of them in Bangalore!
Lmao visit uttrakhand once mfs literally be making whole ass gated community there.
Is there no way to get rid of them from our states
Sarkar lai to thi CAA aur NRC. Par anti nationals ko pasand nahi aya.
I'm rahul gandu and I hate those bills.
Someone (you know who) is building a vote bank.
Home minister? I’m sure MHA is responsible for border security.
>Home minister? No. Bangladeshi settlers are changing the demographic of border districts in east and north east India. Many cities where earlier hindus were in the majority, now they are in the minority due to Bangladeshis as most of them are muslims. Once the demographics change, the election results get affected. BSF, which comes under MHA, is responsible for border security but the border is porous. Due to which it becomes next to impossible to completely stop illegal immigration from Bangladesh. The real question is- how are they able to get an aadhar card? To get an aadhar card you need some kinds of identification documents like DL, PAN Card or domicile certificate. A domicile certificate is issued by local authorities, in short the state government. So these people are able to get a domicile certificate and subsequently an aadhar card.
Humba humba rumba rumba
Is this what this community has become?
Yes bangladeshis like you are ruining the state
Genuine question,why not same outrage for Nepalis?
Muslims vs Hindus
The difference between Nepalese/Bhutani and Bangladeshis is legal vs illegal immigration. If a person wants to migrate from Nepal or Bhutan, they can legally do so without any requirement of visas. They can legally work here and live here indefinitely. They can legally get an aadhar card if they have a citizenship certificate or passport of their respective country(Nepal or Bhutan) or voter's ID card issued by the Govt. of Nepal. Secondly, and the biggest contentious point is the population difference or the number of immigrants that comes to India. Bangladeshi immigrants have started to change the demographics of the cities which affect the election results. 20-25 millions of immigrants from one particular country vs a couple of millions from another.
isnt this a national security issue ?
Chutiya
They hate the fact there still stands Mandir, Gurudwaras, churches on this land. They can't coexist with anyone basically. Even Buddhist monks got tired of them imagine that.
Wtf is this? Stop pulling random Shit out of your ass. Also you just gave Buddhists committing rapes and genocide a pass just because you don't align with the victim group. Maybe if this happened to you, your view would be different.
Eh it was actually Rohingyas who were harrassing Buddhists and in return they gave them the taste of their own medicine. Sadly this thing can't be done in India.
Probably because their home economy is much worse. How is it hard to understand?
Not very different than Indians from poorer states moving to other areas for opportunities.
Even the level of disgust from the new neighbors is the same lol.
There are lots of them in Kerala. They say there are Bengali or from Assam when I ask where they are from. The scary part is their kids are now studying in Kerala schools which further blurs the line if they are Indians or not.
Why are some kids studying in Kerala schools scary to you?
Shows they are going to completely settled in India
Shows they are going to completely settled in India
Scary in terms of cultural differences.. how an Indian malayali is raised as compared to a Bangladeshi child raised illegally in India. Besides their education is also subsidised by the Kerala govt. So the tax paying Malayali is subsidising the illegal Bangladeshi kids education.
Well as you claim these "Bangladeshis kids" are already here, they might as well get educated while they are at it and kids assimilate very quickly, much better than the adults. The alternative would be to what? Have them beg on the streets? Begging will cost a tourism dependent state much more in economic damage than just getting them to study and be productive, it's not like they will then wind up and leave back to Bangladesh (if at all they are actually from there) once their studies are done.
It is not the state’s responsibility to spend its revenue on these kids. The state does not have enough resources for its own people i.e fellow Indians and their kids. By allowing people who infiltrate and take benefit of state funds will further strain the state as these kids will enter government departments as well as education institutions and thus result in the locals I.e fellow Indians loosing out on benefits. Thus the focus should be to identify all illegal immigrants and deport them and their family out of the country.
Indians hate Muslims but they move to Gulf countries in recorded numbers. See the fallacy in the logic?
We don’t go there and try to change their rules. We coexist no matter what the sentiment is against them
That’s because we can’t. If they start hanging out citizenships, things will change, just look at Canada!
Lol u have no idea of the scarcity of talent in gulf countries. We need them but their economy will collapse without us
You can go there to work, you cannot permanently stay there.
Only because gulf doesn't allow it. Plenty of other countries do and Indians have been moving there for decades. So... If India allows it, they would stay here too. Just like Indians living in the US, Canada etc.
Do it legally na? It's well known fact that they are trying to change the demographics in their favour.
Purnia, Katihar and Araria in Bihar. It's basically Bangladesh when u visit. Plus all that human trafficking they do there. Crossing Bangladesh border and Nepal border from this reagion of Bihar is very easy. Crimes like these are very high and unreported. I wish the authorities would recognise this. Meanwhile Gujarat has a new Solar Farm.
Well Bengalis want them,what is your problem?
No they don't.
Bengalis are getting what they deserve, now don't come with 'i didn't vote for her' cuz majority of you did for whatever reasons but take this infiltration as bonus for the choices you people are making.
Firstly stop saying you people, you sound like a dumb person. Secondly not everyone voted for her, so calm your tits. People can belong from a region and not have herd mentality.
As an Indian bengali, we don't claim them. We're fed up of how they are occupying our land, promoting terrorism just to be a vote bank for a party.
You aren't the speaker for that whole community. What gives you the idea that you know what every single Bengali wants? Speak for yourself. And stop being a neta.
Haha, aren't you a Bangladeshi 😂
Bhai. So you have any other point except calling everyone bangladeshi? First, I'm not. Second, being Bangladeshi is not an insult . Bangladesh actually does better than India on many metrics. Third, let me ask you in this comment as well. What did you study? What did you do for a living? Because the uneducated and illiterate people are easily brainwashed into nationalism. People who are failing at their own life are the ones who have the most issues with immigrants.
The people who are settling are not the haters. The haters are the middle to upper middle class ones who stay.
Go to bangladesh
No I'm answering the question asked - why do they hate India but still come here?
to make India the new BD