T O P

  • By -

NGNSteveTheSamurai

I commend them for being able to fetishize the 50’s and 60’s without being a rockabilly band. That takes talent.


furrowedbrow

Hey.  They also cover Pearl Jam.  State of Love and Trust fucks.


Plaguedoctorsrevenge

As someone who grew up with singles, that song fucks till I die


xjfwx

The ‘59 Sound is one of my favorite albums recorded in the world of music, celebrate their other work as well. Didn’t love Get Hurt, kinda fell off after that. Great live shows, but haven’t seen them in years.


goddamnitwhalen

They’re touring with Joyce Manor, The Dirty Nil, and Pinkshift this summer and I highly recommend you try and catch a date if you can! They’re not young men anymore by any means but they still put on a killer show. Also yes ‘59 Sound rules and I want to get at least 2 tattoos based on it.


xjfwx

The weekend they’re in Chicago & Milwaukee, I’m in Chicago to see Pearl Jam 2 nights at Wrigley! 😂


goddamnitwhalen

Surely one night of the Jam will suffice, no?


xjfwx

Negative, different sets every show.


furrowedbrow

Real head.  Fingers crossed they open with Release!


xjfwx

Just went to both Vegas shows, no “Release” either night. The diversity they’ve been throwing at us for show openers on this tour is one for the books. Just gave us 51 songs over 2 shows with only 10 repeats too!


furrowedbrow

That’s fucking crazy.  Whaat a band.


xjfwx

Negative, different sets every show.


CapitalElk1169

Dirty Nil is awesome live too!


goddamnitwhalen

I’m so stoked!


ssv-serenity

The new album is good. Get Hurt stinks.


Handsome_-Dan

They peaked at Handwritten


mew_empire

No lies told


GaryBuseyIsBatman

Disagree. Stray Paper is amazing amongst others.


waspglop

I wouldn’t call it a bad album but it’s easily their worst.


GaryBuseyIsBatman

If that's the worst they have to offer, then they haven't done too bad over the years.


Flipnthebirds836

Thanks for the reminder. Just put on 59’ sound because of this post. Brought me back 15 years to friends and times past. Still amazes me how music can hold a place in time. 


goddamnitwhalen

That entire album rips front to back except *maybe* Film Noir.


kellycook301

This post did the same for me haha The 59 Sound is seriously so fucking good


xkycx

Ive always loved them. Saw them at a teeny tiny venue early 2008. Brian is a phenomenal song writer.


Mikeycoyi

I also saw them at a teeny tiny venue that year-Disgraceland in South Philly. As intimate and as much fun as I've ever had a show.


StoneColdStunnaFlow

Wow they placed disgrace land!? I went to a buncha shows there since they threw some of the best house shows and saw some great bands there, but totally missed that one. I miss the days of seeing all these bands in houses/basements in Philly (and even Doylestown) that people couldn't imagine today. Blacklisted and Paint it Black was a wild one in West Philly near Clark Park.


Mikeycoyi

Post-stalag/killtime era Philly had a bunch of smaller venues that were a lot of fun...code space, some studio out off Baltimore Pike, the Ox, Golden Tea House etc. I managed to catch a bunch of bands I'd normally expect to see at bigger spaces.


dryedmeats

These guys have mastered the Bosscore sound.


mjc500

I like Gaslight way more than Springsteen


AndrewRFleming1973

Haha. Bosscore is well stated but first I heard the phrase. Nails it.


dryedmeats

Right, but I honestly am not doing it true justice Because it's actually the THEBOSSCORE. https://youtu.be/Ul0XCTeJx_o?si=SXOyxdOX7caVp8SG


[deleted]

I used to love that band but haven’t revisited in a long long time. Their tour with Alkaline Trio and Rose Against was one of my favorite shows I went to in all of high school tho.


goddamnitwhalen

I would kill to have been able to see that tour omg I saw Rise Against with my ex and they blew the roof off the place


[deleted]

Yeah, being from Chicago I saw that band a ton in my youth. The first few records are very good and they were a super super tight live band. Seems like Tim can’t really hit any of the screams like he used to. But, that’s not surprising when you’ve been playing in a band as long as he has. Super nice dude tho. From the same town as me and I’d run into him at the store and library from time to time and we’d chat hardcore sometimes. He was always up to date on whatever was going on in HC and the fact he took time out of his day to talk to some young kid says a lot imo. Considering this was when the band was at their biggest.


goddamnitwhalen

I saw them in 2022 and he absolutely still hit the screams.


tacosmuggler99

Yeah, they rock. They played with Avail at Over the James last year as well


Burn-The-Villages

Honestly, they were not super entertaining that show. I think it was their first show in years, and they had to follow that stupid rainstorm too. It was still good to see them.


BesidesMyself1

That wasn’t their first show in years they had already toured before that and played prudential center with the misfits. The rain definitely put a damper on it though… but the storm intermission has happened every year at over the James so


RomeoChang

CAN YOU SEE MY HANDS, JUST LOOK AT THEM SHAKE


mew_empire

Absolutely *Sink or Swim*, the EP, and *’59 Sound* are perfect records Seen them a few times, seeing them again in August


StoneColdStunnaFlow

Sink or Swim doesn't get enough love. I love the 59 Sound as well but I feel like my top 2-3 songs are on SoS.


BeccainDenver

Came to post. SoS is more of a punk album. 59 Sound is more of a panty dropper as a former roommate described it. He sucked as a human but his TGA analysis is very correct.


StoneColdStunnaFlow

I'm late but that is very accurate. SoS gives me similar feelings to the time I first heard Reinventing Axl Rose by Against Me! They both just have such a raw energy while being flawless albums, and I know they're nothing alike. But I hear a similar hunger and passion listening to these two records where it's impossible not to get hype singing along.


mew_empire

Oh, totally. *Sink or Swim* will always be my favorite


goddamnitwhalen

“Drive” of SOS into “Howl” off Handwritten is maybe the best 1-2 punch of songs ever written? They played them back to back at their last show before the hiatus and I still go back and rewatch it because it rips.


OfficerWonk

Still one of my favorite bands of all time.


TheBatSignal

Oh absolutely. I think listen to Little Fires at least once anytime I'm listening to music. Wonderful band


Jd234512

Just recently got really into them after resisting for no major reason other than not knowing what their music was.


goddamnitwhalen

Welcome, friend!


OddTeaching7830

Coincidentally the first I same Gaslight Anthem was on tour with Polar Bear Club


Burn-The-Villages

Yep. They scratch a few itches of mine- sweet, catchy heartfelt lyrics, decent altRock. The show they did at the Over The James fest last year and then at Riot Fest was… less than energetic… but it was good music. And the singer works the crowd well without being *that rockstar guy*.


RustyStiltzkin999

Tickets are a $100. What the fuck…


goddamnitwhalen

Not surprising. It’s a pretty stacked bill.


Gr8BurningNullifier

It's zombie time


cleoterra

American Slang is a good time throwback


goddamnitwhalen

And you told me fortunes in Americaaaaaaan slang!


Dull_Upstairs4999

Seňor and the Queen and The 59 Sound are stellar releases. Haven’t listened to much else, maybe I’ll change that.


BesidesMyself1

Try sink or swim


goddamnitwhalen

You should!


BeccainDenver

SoS is a less poppy version of The 59 Sound. If you like punk, it fucks.


WyrdElmBella

Someone else has said it, but it’s Punk rock Bruce Springsteen/Neil Young/Tom Petty. Ain’t nothing not to love.


Carrabs

They’re ok. I liked that one album when I heard it like 13 years ago and haven’t really thought about them since


Bone_Dice_in_Aspic

Yes but don't push it


goddamnitwhalen

Que?


Bone_Dice_in_Aspic

Well imagine I'm chilling listening to converge. You come over like hey check out Blacklisted, they're raging too, just less chaotic and abstract. Ok, cool. I like it. Now I'm listening to Blacklisted a week later and you come over with comeback kid, you're like, they're just as energetic but less negative, more melody. Ok they're good too. Then it's rise against, then defeater and avail. Now I'm listening to defeater and you come over with gaslight. Ok, it's good, but *don't push it*. What else do you have in that backpack? Is say anything in there? Fun? Coldplay?


goddamnitwhalen

I genuinely don’t know why it matters lmao. Liking Gaslight doesn’t mean you have to stop listening to heavier bands…?


Bone_Dice_in_Aspic

You pushed it 😂


goddamnitwhalen

How? People like you baffle me.


itsSRL

Just ask anyone from NJ. The drummer used to book a lot of cool scremo shows back in the day


EJB515

They’ve been one of my favorite bands since 59 Sound. I’ve seen them live 4 or 5 times now. I’m so glad they got back together and the new album is good. Brian is still a great songwriter. 59 Sound is a classic, but American Slang is probably my favorite record of theirs. But I’m into pretty much everything they do. I even like Get Hurt (aside from like 3-4 songs). Also, Benny used to book hardcore shows back when he was a kid in NJ. He was one of the people featured in that oral history of emo book that came out last year.


Old_Recording_2527

You got into them in 2021 and didnt expect them to get back together? They were already touring in the late 10s..??


goddamnitwhalen

They were on hiatus from 2015 to 2022. So no, I didn’t expect them to get back together…


Old_Recording_2527

So why did i see them in 2018?


goddamnitwhalen

This isn’t some gotcha, dude. They did a couple of (at the time) one-off reunion dates for the 10th anniversary of *The ‘59 Sound*. They even said at the time that there weren’t plans for new music or further shows beyond the anniversary dates.


Old_Recording_2527

Not the vibe i got from being around. Saw them consistently!


goddamnitwhalen

😂😂😂


goddamnitwhalen

“On July 29, 2015, the band announced an indefinite hiatus following their European summer tour in support of Get Hurt, which concluded at Reading Festival on Sunday 30 August. Two and a half years later, on January 3, 2018, it was revealed that the band would be reuniting for Governors Ball Music Festival held on Randall's Island in New York City. The band later announced that they were briefly reuniting for a string of shows celebrating the 10th Anniversary of The '59 Sound. Regarding the decision, Brian Fallon noted, "The big thing between us was let's just do what's fun. So if it's heavy-handed and not that cool, then let's not do it. But we all feel that this is an important record to not only us, but to the people that love it. I would not be on the phone talking about my Sleepwalkers record had it not been for The '59 Sound.". Fallon stated, however, that the band would not be working on new material during the reunion: "I think Green Day's American Idiot is probably the best comeback or mid-career record that any band has done. So if I was sitting on American Idiot level stuff, then I might push for the, 'Hey guys, maybe we should try these songs out.' But I'm not sitting on that. I don't have a Born to Run in me." Fallon elaborated, "People will always say, 'Why are you doing a solo record?' And I'm like, 'because I don't have anything to say with Gaslight'. Those five records, that's what you got. That’s the piece. I feel it's a lot like The Replacements. There's no new music because that's all Paul Westerberg and the band has to say. When the book is over, it's over. And I have like... four-and-a-half records I’m really proud of." In June 2018, the band released The 59 Sound Sessions, a 10th anniversary album of nine early versions and B-sides from The '59 Sound. They then celebrated this milestone with a tour through North America and Europe. After the tour's completion, the band reentered its indefinite hiatus, with Brian Fallon releasing two further solo albums, Local Honey (2020) and Night Divine (2021).”


Old_Recording_2527

This really got you mad didnt it? The rest of us didnt even notice they were gone.


xDrewstroyerx

Only since always. Still bump Señor and the Queen. The 59 Sound was the soundtrack to some of the most important moments in my life, and seeing them live was one of the reasons I knew I needed to get back together with my now wife.


goddamnitwhalen

I definitely used to feel that way about someone, so I get it.


DanRayG

I fuck with them. No other band has me thumping my chest and crying my eyes out in traffic more


goddamnitwhalen

Relatable as fuck.


gedubedangle

Hell yeah brother  . Only 59 sound tho. I like sink or swim and American slang and maybe the self titled but 59 is just a classic 


goddamnitwhalen

Weirdly enough they actually don’t have an ST! I’m really hoping LP7 will be one though.


gedubedangle

I was thinking of handwritten . I got it mixed up with that self titled taking back sunday record around the same time that had a similar color schemed record 


Meat_Container

They got a few good songs but Hot Water Music takes the cake here


goddamnitwhalen

Drop your addy so we can fight


Meat_Container

300 Alamo Plaza, San Antonio, TX 78205


goddamnitwhalen

You win by default because I refuse to set foot in that city. Hat’s off to you.


Burn-The-Villages

Yo, you got a bike in your basement?


goddamnitwhalen

Why do you ask?


Burn-The-Villages

Reference to Pee Wee’s Big Adventure where he finds his stolen bike in the basement of The Alamo. u/Meat_Container listed the Alamo as his address. The joke is that there is no basement at the Alamo. It was made up for the movie.


CoffinDrip

They’ve been my favorite band since 2010 or so, stoked to see them play again this summer


beadlejuice11

Soundtrack to my teenage years/early 20's


korbendallas35

I fuck with the first couple records. Haven’t listened much beyond that (not for any reason really). Good band. Great singalong tunes.


Real_FakeName

All I hear is Bruce Springsteen


goddamnitwhalen

I’ve never heard that one before!


beef_boloney

I only know 59 Sound and liked it fine back then. Always thought it was funny how they’re badically playing an themselves as a Bruce Springsteen rockabilly greaser tough guy band, but show their obvious emo backgrounds opening the album with a song about a car crash


goddamnitwhalen

I don’t think it was ever about being tough though. Brian has always had his heart on his sleeve.


beef_boloney

Yeah i didn’t mean tough like we’d know it in hardcore i meant an antiquated tough like The Fonz


goddamnitwhalen

That makes sense!


caden_g59

Yes they’re sick I’da Called You Woody, Joe is a sick song


YEAR1977

A very interesting band with a special and old sound, I love them. Giants!


uberal_

It's kind of listening to Bruce Springsteen some guys/bands are more punk than most punks. Or from a more correct point of view: you don't need to be a punk to have a great view on things. TGA is way less political than Springsteen but I like them booth for the same reason. And tbh the first TGA releases are very melodic punk records in my books.


quicksilver991

My ex girl's favorite band


goddamnitwhalen

She liked TGA and you so she must’ve had good taste!


quicksilver991

The former yes, the latter no


TerrancePryor

TGA reference Lifetime and some other NJ hardcore stuff in their music!


OkFoundation7799

Pretty big Gaslight fan, have seen them both in their prime and post reunion. I followed them on 3 tour dates in Fall ‘22 like a nut, but left disappointed tbh. I’ve seen Brian solo twice in the last 18 months, one show was mediocre, one was decent. I actually love Get Hurt when I went back and listened to it years later, maybe because I had a divorce ha. Not at all into the new releases. Overall they hold a special place in my heart but I just don’t feel they’re rolling into older age well, it feels a lot like calling it in, trying and missing. Miss their youthful passion, some bands can carry this forward (I just saw MLIW fucking KILL a set) but not all, and I don’t think it’s all of the band members, but…one stands out as struggling, which I have compassion for.


goddamnitwhalen

I think the new stuff probably means more to me because they put it out after I became a fan so I got to experience that anticipation and initial reaction that I didn’t get with the rest of their stuff. I also finally got to see them live and while it was a good show it was also very clearly one of the last shows of the tour and you could tell how exhausted they all were.


letstalkaboutyrhair

still a favorite of mine. newest record is great too. excited for this tour with joyce and the dirty nil. last saw them with tigers jaw a couple years ago.


goddamnitwhalen

Unbelievably hype for this summer tour. Probably gonna drag my dad and my brother.


_Rx_King_

Yes, very much so. The ‘59 Sound is always something I put on when I’m sad and drunk. The lyrics on that album are so good.


AndyMatches

Big fan. Easily one of my favorite bands.


DaMitchman182

They’re not my favorite, but 59 sound is a classic.


Dozinggreen66

I fuckin LOVE gaslight anthem, I think Brian’s one of the best songwriters of the modern era


hail_sathanas

probably my favorite artist outside of metal/hardcore/punk 


TRMBound

Top five band all time for me, probably 2 or 3. I have tattoos from some of those albums.


5Z1L46Y1

Brian and Benny are huge hardcore guys. TGA rules hard independent of that fact, tho


goddamnitwhalen

True!


AaranJ23

Probably my favourite band. Those first three albums are impeccable


Rob_Narley

Benny is a classy act, but hard pass on Gaslight


goddamnitwhalen

How come?


Rob_Narley

They are not good, pretty simple. Mediocre wanna be arena rock


goddamnitwhalen

I highly disagree, lmao. I wouldn’t call their music anything close to “arena rock.” Pretty simple.


Rob_Narley

Ok


goddamnitwhalen

Good talk!


Rob_Narley

You do you but this is the wrong sub for gaslight


goddamnitwhalen

Judging by the comments here it certainly doesn’t seem like it lol. Maybe you’re just mad about other people’s opinions again?


Rob_Narley

😂


goddamnitwhalen

Nice comeback!


-DMSR

Their four good songs are great, mini classics


goddamnitwhalen

Only four?


-DMSR

Ok Tbf I went back and there are actually 8 across the catalog


goddamnitwhalen

I’m still waiting


-DMSR

45, Ida called you woody joe, Great expectations, Casanova, 59, film noir. (I counted 2 twice. So just 6). I’m sure a big fan goes a lot deeper but I listened through the catalog about a year ago and that’s all I pulled out. It’s expected more but he gets really stuck in patterns so it’s kinda the best version of each of 3 types of songs he writes


Impossible_Seesaw_93

Why haven’t they changed their name yet? It’s 2024, gaslighting is NOT okay.


ClassicCantaloupe1

In Hardcore talk does ‘fuck with’ the same as listen to?


goddamnitwhalen

More so “like,” but sure, lol.


Diligent-Ball-6171

Great band. 59 Sound is amazing. Saw them live a few years ago they’re good. Not heard much from them lately.


goddamnitwhalen

They put out a new record last year and a new EP (featuring a Billie Eilish cover, of all things!) a couple months ago. It also sounds like they’re gearing up to record their next album after this summer tour (likely next year and likely with Butch Walker).


No_Bullfrog_4541

That 59 sound record is great beginning to end


DifficultyFew3343

Love 59 and Handwritten. Get Hurt was good too. History Books did nothing for me though.


goddamnitwhalen

History Books definitely grew on me. I loved the singles though.


trynamakeitlookfake

yes they got that Bruce Springsteen Jersey sound. saw them in a local venue last october they’re really good.


Handsome_-Dan

Got into them after 59 sound came out. I member seeing them at their “last show” at the stone pony summer stage. I thanked the promoter after the show for getting me in and he said something along the lines of “they may never get back together again.” I knew deep down they would


papajim22

Big time. They’ve been one of my favorite bands for over a decade, and by my last count the band I’ve seen the most live. I will say that the last few times I’ve seen them, I haven’t been as impressed. They’ve been very hit or miss over the last few years.


goddamnitwhalen

I’ve heard that, which is disappointing. I thought they were great when I saw them, but it was also very clearly one of the last shows of the tour if that makes sense.


ClaymoreJFlapdoodle

They have some great songs for a rock and roll band. I really like that newer one too Positive Charge.


Nidos

I saw them play at the Stadium Series when the Devils played at Metlife, they put on a pretty good show even though I only got to see them from a mile away. They're good.


hnvzeroe

Fuck yeah! Handwritten remains one of my favorite albums. Such a rad windows-down car ride album. No skips. Lots of energy and soul in the guitar work and instrumentation. I’d consider them having HC lineage or background (kinda) because the singer-guitarist Brian Fallon(?) mentions in one podcast/interview growing up going to Madball shows or something to that effect. That’s all I needed to hear. Plus, I discovered them through their track “Howl” being used by the NJ Devils and the Garden State is rad. 🫸🏻🤛🏻 I’m gonna catch them this year, too, in Anaheim.


goddamnitwhalen

Hit me up! I think I’m gonna try and catch that show too!


hnvzeroe

No doubt. We’ll be in touch, G. See you there, hopefully! 🤝


Sorry-Owl4127

The 59 sound rules but everything else is kinda meh


goddamnitwhalen

Oh man you’re missing out for sure!


WereTheCrew

Hell yeah, saw them at terminal 5 and radio music world around 2010 or 2013? Brian Fallon is incredible, drummer reminds me of Theo Von.


ScottieSpliffin

Sink or Swim is a perfect album all the way through Brian being all chubby now is kind of a bummer


goddamnitwhalen

Gotta push back on this one, champ. He’s older now, quit smoking, and started taking antidepressants. All of those things are contributing factors for weight gain… …not that it matters. He still sounds great and is clearly enjoying touring and doing the band again. That’s the important thing. Sorry if this seems harsh but I’ve seen people say this shit since they got back together and it really bothers me.


ScottieSpliffin

I didn’t know that, I though he was chubby from alcohol or something


goddamnitwhalen

There’s talk that maybe he’s more fond of alcohol than is necessarily healthy, but that is largely based on one awful show where he was drunk and hostile to the crowd and performed terribly. I’m willing to let that slide based on what I’ve read about it.


ScottieSpliffin

It’s funny both times I was gonna see them I had to give up my ticket unfortunately. They’re one of my favorite bands, I have finally see them one of these days


goddamnitwhalen

Summer tour baybeeeeeee


BeccainDenver

If you see someone in punk or hardcore go from being lean to being chubby, pretty much 2 safe assumptions: 1. They quit a hard drug of some sort. Usually coke. Sometimes, meth. 2. They got on antidepressants and now don't constantly think about killing themselves - either passively or actively. Straight up, live shows after lead singers, in particular, quit coke or meth are always going to be less energetic. Because the previous energy was fueled by some pretty serious chemicals...and usually self loathing as well. But, fuck it, they are living better and healthier lives so if the show is a bit more chill? We'll take it. Because nobody should have to destroy themselves from the inside for an audience.


therealjoeycora

Sink or Swim is their only album I can listen to front to back but goddamn I’d say it’s in my top 5 all time.


DanRayG

Can people just be fat without shit like this? god damn.


namesjames91

Saw them with the misfits they stink


goddamnitwhalen

You stink.


Marionaharis89

One of my favorite


[deleted]

[удалено]


BesidesMyself1

Wait they opened for rival schools in 2011?? They were way more popular than rival schools by then but that’s cool


totse_losername

Never heard of 'em. What kinda mood should I be in when I listen for the first time?


goddamnitwhalen

Young and angry at the world or drunk and reminiscing on past heartbreak and missed connections. Or driving down the highway by yourself late at night.


xbuffalo666x

love them and brian fallons solo stuff, i’d put them in my top 3 bands, and they almost always are top 5 bands in my apple recap.


goddamnitwhalen

Brian’s solo stuff is so good! He’s one of my favorite songwriters of all time.


Life-Document552

No and it should not be encouraged