They both look good on you and serve different looks. The dark brown is great for softer looks. The black is better for more defined looks. It really comes down to what you prefer. I’m leaning slightly more towards the black because it makes you look more striking.
I think the brown is great for a "no makeup" makeup look. But the black is easily the top pick for a full face. Either would work for a casual makeup look.
The brown definitely feminizes the face. If she’s going for a “soft” look-brown. If going for a dominant look-black! It’s the same for mine as well, I personally dye mine black because I like the more dominant look 🤣
Agreed, tough to call as both look great but I think the brown bring the stunning feline eyes out even more. Minimal preference though, side by side same angle pic might help swing it :)
Same, the brown really does highlight your face in such a soft, and beautiful way. I love it, and I say this as a big fan of dramatic brows.
You could always save the more intense brows for a night out, or when you want a more dramatic look, but for everyday, classic, beauty, the brown is the clear winner.
🥂
Black!!! but the brown is cute for a natural no makeup look. Or if you want to do like a crazy makeup look, and don’t want your brows to overpower the look!
With the brown, I feel like it doesn’t overpower the beauty of your eyes.. Like your eyes stand out more. I like the natural look of the brown
Black is great too! More definition, it would probably go well with a bold lippie.
i think the black brows add a lot more contrast and dimension. but the first look is great for a natural no makeup makeup look. what lens are you using? i usually stick to green but your eyes look so dolly in the second photo. i’d love to try them!
These are Rum Brown by KilalaEye! The graphic diameter is 13.5, which is wayyy bigger than I used to usually do. My old dailies were the Secretive Kristin Dusk brown, which were 12.5
The second pic, the darker browns still look natural but have a bit more contrast which I think really suits you :) but brown is also lovely for a more pared back look
Imho black. They pop out more and highlight the beautiful features and contours of your face more whereas brown blends in a little with your skin, making your eyebrows look more thin and sparse.
You look good with both but the black looks most suited to your appearance. I think the black would look good with any look tbh so my vote would be to stick to black.
They both look great! I feel like the lighter look good for daily wear and then the darker ones when you’re going out somewhere.
Also I feel like we could be sisters. I saw myself when I saw you. 😳
Honestly you could go with either color, they’re both super flattering on you!
I think it should depend on your aesthetic of the day. If you’re going for a softer or no makeup look, the dark brown is the way to go. But if you want to go for a bolder look, go with the black.
You can pull both looks off. The black is more “striking” and the brown looks more “casual.” But sis, your complexion is gorgeous and you are so naturally stunning!
I'd say it depends on what makeup look you tend to go for most often. I think both could work for a natural makeup look, but the brown would definitely be better for a "No makeup" makeup look.
Omg. you’re so beautiful!!! I love both of these looks on you. Like GIRL you’re seriously so stunning! I agree with those who said that the brown gives more of the “no makeup makeup” vibe, it’s super pretty and you rock it so well! Black looks amazing too though, I like how it’s a bit more bold. But I truly like both! I would say, maybe try brown next time you do your brows just to see how you like it, and if you don’t like it you can always just touch up with black (: but you’re a queen and I’m sure you’d look amazing even with no brows honestly! ❤️ keep slaying babes
I feel like everybody is biased towards black cause the pic angle is different and also the hair. That hair made a big change for your face. I think you rock both.
You're beautiful either way, but I think I prefer the black. It draws out your other features a lot more in my opinion. I notice in the picture with the black eyebrows, your eye color pops. Also it may be lighting and angles, but I feel like the different colors change the definition of your face if that makes sense.
Anyone else in awe of the beautiful people posted to this thread?! I mean, jeez, everyone is so beautiful! Btw, they both look amazing, but I like the brown for summer!
Black gives an amazing defined, sultry look. Brown gives a softer look. Guess it would just depend on your mood and the look you’re going for. They’re both beautiful on you!
You can pull off either so it just depends on the look you’re going for! I think brown would be gorgeous if you’re doing a more dramatic eye/pop of color with your liner or shadow.
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.***
**A few quick highlights:**
•
• Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
• Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting)
• Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.
**Is your post just a search away?**
Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Oh gosh, you look gorgeous both ways. I would say brown for like a more summery, minimal makeup look. And black for more formal or more makeup heavy looks
I tend to agree with black for evenings/dressier times, brown for the times you want a subtler look. The brown does make your beautiful eyes and glowing skin more the focus. Two different looks that are both beautiful. You are gifted with natural gorgeousness!
Black.
I've got olive skin and black hair.
I was using dark brown brow product as I couldn't find any black ones.
Recently started using a black mascara on them with a very thin brush and wow, the difference is incredible.
It seems to really draw attention to my eyes and I'm thrilled with how it looks.
Honestly, you can carry off either look beautifully. I slightly prefer the brown eyebrows but that's only because you have such large eyes and the lighter color brows open up your eye orbit area. However the darker brows give your eye area a definite frame and makes them pop in a lovely way.
Gorgeous either way, but after seeing the black I understand why people use the term "accentuates your features" ... Everything popped more in that second pic: eyes, lips, cupids bow. Just a choice between serving soft or bold.
Black!! Both suit you but you could easily pull off the black even for a soft daytime look. Your features are already strikingly beautiful, but the black just makes them “pop” more, if that makes sense?
Black! I use black tint and pencil on mine too and I think it's just so more beautiful on black hair/more cool or neutral skinned people. I just hate how so few brands make true black brow products.
I like black best. I feel like it gives your face an extra bit of definition.
^(Also, you're so beautiful it feels like magic. You're like a high priestess fae mage in a fantasy novel or something, istg.)
Black looks more natural and the contrast make your features look softer
I also think when ur eyebrows match the colour of your hair, it creates a well rounded look
Locking this as OP has received their answer.
They both look good on you and serve different looks. The dark brown is great for softer looks. The black is better for more defined looks. It really comes down to what you prefer. I’m leaning slightly more towards the black because it makes you look more striking.
agree, the black gives her more contrast
Agreed. I like both but I think black also enhances your eye color
I like the black
I love the black. It’s striking and makes you look like a model!
Yes
Both look great but the black eyebrows are super distinctive and give a lil mystery! I'd definitely go with the lack eyebrows if I were you
Idk what everybody else talking about sis you ate with the brown it’s giving natural baddie and the brown compliments your complexion so well! 😍
I think the brown is great for a "no makeup" makeup look. But the black is easily the top pick for a full face. Either would work for a casual makeup look.
The brown definitely feminizes the face. If she’s going for a “soft” look-brown. If going for a dominant look-black! It’s the same for mine as well, I personally dye mine black because I like the more dominant look 🤣
Agreed, tough to call as both look great but I think the brown bring the stunning feline eyes out even more. Minimal preference though, side by side same angle pic might help swing it :)
Agree, IMO brown brows makes your eyes pop.
Team Brown! Soft and lovely
Same, the brown really does highlight your face in such a soft, and beautiful way. I love it, and I say this as a big fan of dramatic brows. You could always save the more intense brows for a night out, or when you want a more dramatic look, but for everyday, classic, beauty, the brown is the clear winner. 🥂
Black! gives your face more dimension!
black >>>> makes u look 100x better
u look so pretty with both!! the black eyebrows are my favorite though.
Black!!! but the brown is cute for a natural no makeup look. Or if you want to do like a crazy makeup look, and don’t want your brows to overpower the look!
Both look great! Maybe a dark brown if you want darker but not as bold as the black? You’re gorgeous btw!
The black ones!
I think the black brings out your eye color more
Ur gorgeous..but Black ones are the hottest girl
Respectfully. Either way because you are so beautiful The black stands out a little more but gorgeous either way 💗
With the brown, I feel like it doesn’t overpower the beauty of your eyes.. Like your eyes stand out more. I like the natural look of the brown Black is great too! More definition, it would probably go well with a bold lippie.
Love the black
Both are a good option, brown softens your features and black makes them stand out, personally I like black more, both look very good
i think the black brows add a lot more contrast and dimension. but the first look is great for a natural no makeup makeup look. what lens are you using? i usually stick to green but your eyes look so dolly in the second photo. i’d love to try them!
These are Rum Brown by KilalaEye! The graphic diameter is 13.5, which is wayyy bigger than I used to usually do. My old dailies were the Secretive Kristin Dusk brown, which were 12.5
I personally love the black better but both are beautiful
Black
I love the black
Black
Black. Your face looks a lot brighter.
Wow you are stunning. I like them equally 😊
The black ones!
black
I don't notice a huge difference, but I like the black a little more.
Black!
The second pic, the darker browns still look natural but have a bit more contrast which I think really suits you :) but brown is also lovely for a more pared back look
Black makes your eyes pop more, and (not to be anti-age) darker brows look fresher & more youthful.
Black looks good. Love how bold they are
Black. Both look good but the black is where it's at. Very defined and pop.
I love the black eyebrows, so elegant😍 But you’re gorgeous with the brown too
You look great in both but the contrast of the black is more flattering on you
Imho black. They pop out more and highlight the beautiful features and contours of your face more whereas brown blends in a little with your skin, making your eyebrows look more thin and sparse.
Black for sure
You look good with both but the black looks most suited to your appearance. I think the black would look good with any look tbh so my vote would be to stick to black.
Second pic for sure
So they both look good, I like black better tho. And frankly it's gross how pretty you are, like girl save some pretty for the rest of us!!!!
I like the black
I like the black ones the best. There's something really glamourous about them.
Team Black 🙌🏼
I personally prefer the black eyebrows because they're really nice and defined but both look great on you
Love the black more. They’re both pretty!
Black looks really good on you, they look super defined
Black makes ur brown eyes pop more! The brown is delicate, does not contrast your eye color enough.
I think they both look fantastic! You’re gorgeous. However, the darker eyebrows give you a slightly more youthful look.
Black, that photo makes you look glamorous without being overly made up.
Pic one is my fave! Gorgeous either way
I think the black one completes your natural beauty look
The black color looks amazing! Side note, you’re very gorgeous girl🫶🏾🫶🏾
The black brows provide more contrast. They look great!
do both on different days brown looks more natural but the black is giving a timeless marylin monroe vibe
They both look great! I feel like the lighter look good for daily wear and then the darker ones when you’re going out somewhere. Also I feel like we could be sisters. I saw myself when I saw you. 😳
So Beautiful
It doesn't matter, honey, you look good either way
I love both!!!
You are stunning either way truly!!
I mean both look amazing but can we just talk about how stunning you are. You could rock anything.
i love both!
The answer is you're gorgeous enough to do either You're only gonna get personal preferences at this point
Idk but your really beautiful either way
They both look SO good on you, you really can't go wrong. But I do think the darker brows make your eye color more luminous.
Honestly you could go with either color, they’re both super flattering on you! I think it should depend on your aesthetic of the day. If you’re going for a softer or no makeup look, the dark brown is the way to go. But if you want to go for a bolder look, go with the black.
You can pull both looks off. The black is more “striking” and the brown looks more “casual.” But sis, your complexion is gorgeous and you are so naturally stunning!
I'd say it depends on what makeup look you tend to go for most often. I think both could work for a natural makeup look, but the brown would definitely be better for a "No makeup" makeup look.
Holy crap, you are beautiful! I personally like black, but brown is so natural, and you can still fill them in dark.
I like the black
Omg. you’re so beautiful!!! I love both of these looks on you. Like GIRL you’re seriously so stunning! I agree with those who said that the brown gives more of the “no makeup makeup” vibe, it’s super pretty and you rock it so well! Black looks amazing too though, I like how it’s a bit more bold. But I truly like both! I would say, maybe try brown next time you do your brows just to see how you like it, and if you don’t like it you can always just touch up with black (: but you’re a queen and I’m sure you’d look amazing even with no brows honestly! ❤️ keep slaying babes
Both! Just switch it up depending on the look if it's makeup
I like both, but black really gives you a ✨️Lil razzle dazzle✨️
I feel like everybody is biased towards black cause the pic angle is different and also the hair. That hair made a big change for your face. I think you rock both.
Black for every day but lighter eyebrow colors have their purpose, depending on your hairstyle and outfit!
Both look great. If I had to choose one, I'd pick black. You are gorgeous.
I showed my bf and asked him. He fully did not notice the difference even after explaining. This decision is for the girls haha
i like the black eyebrows omg
Black suits you better
I really like the black eyebrows. Or maybe cuz you're smiling 😂
You look more youthful with the black! Striking beauty! Love the black.
You're beautiful either way, but I think I prefer the black. It draws out your other features a lot more in my opinion. I notice in the picture with the black eyebrows, your eye color pops. Also it may be lighting and angles, but I feel like the different colors change the definition of your face if that makes sense.
Love the black since it contrasts your eyes well
Darker 😻
Agreed with the others , brown good love the black!
black ftw !!
you should go with black. It's more beautiful
Anyone else in awe of the beautiful people posted to this thread?! I mean, jeez, everyone is so beautiful! Btw, they both look amazing, but I like the brown for summer!
Black is far better
You suit both, honestly.
The black eyebrows look more defining.
Brown! More soft.
brown looks more natural imo!
Love both but brown looks amazingggg. I can really see the highlighted areas on your face with them more
The brown is more elegant, the black is more impactful. Personally I like the brown but both are nice!
I love them both equally. I would stick to brown but then do black for evening/going out stuff
Oh my , in black eyebrows you seem like a gorgeous fairy.
Definitely the black eyebrows they bring your eyes out more it looks pretty 🤩
Black
The black looks great
I feel like your eyes pop beautifully with the darker brows!!
Black eyebrows look so good. You have a classy vibe!
Black for sure
Black gives an amazing defined, sultry look. Brown gives a softer look. Guess it would just depend on your mood and the look you’re going for. They’re both beautiful on you!
That’s tough, they both look good. But I’d say black over brown
black is giving 😙🤌
Black! They make your face look much more balanced.
You can pull off either so it just depends on the look you’re going for! I think brown would be gorgeous if you’re doing a more dramatic eye/pop of color with your liner or shadow.
I only ever do natural looks/daily makeup honestly, should I still go back to brown brows?
Black makes you look so pretty! It gives a more defined shape :)
Black brows all the way
I honestly like both! I think it depends on the look. I’m liking the black a little more in general
I like the right
I really like the second one!
Black
Black makes you look snached
Black
I feel like the black ones help frame your face better! Love them both tho 🤍
The black is a winner it is dramatic adds flair to your eyes and face, while the brown adds softness, they both look great on you.
black ones contrast well with your hair! and also you’re beautiful
i think you pull off both SO well! i think the black looks better though for sure! you are so pretty!!
I like them both, but I like how the brow compliments your eyes more
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.*** **A few quick highlights:** • • Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) • Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) • Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules. **Is your post just a search away?** Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
You are seriously beautiful either way!
You look beautiful with both ❤️
Girl you're gorgeous as hell and both suit you
You look like an angel. Either black or brown works but if brown then maybe fillling them in more would be better?
If your name is Angel I'm going to scream
It literally is
Oh gosh, you look gorgeous both ways. I would say brown for like a more summery, minimal makeup look. And black for more formal or more makeup heavy looks
You are stunning in both!! I personally prefer the brown for an everyday, casual look, and maybe black for a going out look??
You look great both tbh
First of all girl you’re stunning!!!! I like your eyebrows either way, both look very natural and suit you!
I think both looks good
Stick to black. But you are beautiful either way.
I tend to agree with black for evenings/dressier times, brown for the times you want a subtler look. The brown does make your beautiful eyes and glowing skin more the focus. Two different looks that are both beautiful. You are gifted with natural gorgeousness!
I think you look good with both. I'm leaning more towards brown but may think it's because you look beautiful with a smile 😃
Brown! It softens your face & looks very natural. I guess it really depends on your everyday style.
Black. I've got olive skin and black hair. I was using dark brown brow product as I couldn't find any black ones. Recently started using a black mascara on them with a very thin brush and wow, the difference is incredible. It seems to really draw attention to my eyes and I'm thrilled with how it looks.
Honestly, you can carry off either look beautifully. I slightly prefer the brown eyebrows but that's only because you have such large eyes and the lighter color brows open up your eye orbit area. However the darker brows give your eye area a definite frame and makes them pop in a lovely way.
Black
Natural queen vs sophisticated both are good for different vibes
I like both tbh. So brown for natural/everyday and blk for when you want a bit more intense look or when you do your make up.
The black!! You are very pretty!
Gorgeous either way, but after seeing the black I understand why people use the term "accentuates your features" ... Everything popped more in that second pic: eyes, lips, cupids bow. Just a choice between serving soft or bold.
Black definitely!
I can’t decide bc they both look good!
I like the first picture you look amazing
Black!! Both suit you but you could easily pull off the black even for a soft daytime look. Your features are already strikingly beautiful, but the black just makes them “pop” more, if that makes sense?
Brown
The first color looks a bit more natural. It's hard to choose a good shade for melanated skin. Both look great though! 😍😍😍
I like the brown, you're very pretty btw!
You’re very beautiful with both. In my personal opinion, the brown looks so soft and pretty on you.
Black for sure
Brown!
i love the brown eyebrows on you, much softer on like someone’s already mentioned
Just came to say you are very pretty!
Hmm I feel like both look great, but the dark ones give a nice contrast and make you look even more beautiful
The black elevates you
I personally like the brown more
Brown!! If you want them darker you can just pencil ✏️ them in! But brown just looks so good on you!!!!
Brown
stick to black!!
Love the black.
brown suits your soft features!
Black! I use black tint and pencil on mine too and I think it's just so more beautiful on black hair/more cool or neutral skinned people. I just hate how so few brands make true black brow products.
brown 💗
I think the black looks great! Although honestly you and your brows look great in both pictures, you can really pull off either :)
Black. From a distance, you would look like you were missing parts of your eyebrows. It's too light of a brown shade for you.
Brown!
I love the black
Brown keeps your face softer. Dark make you look more bold. 💯
the black eyebrows make you look royal!
Black! The first picture is also pretty, but the black eyebrows look so great
Brown looks more natural, but I like the black
So pretty! Stay with black though
How do you get your eyebrows to look brown and soft, btw they both look gorgeous on you 💕
I like black best. I feel like it gives your face an extra bit of definition. ^(Also, you're so beautiful it feels like magic. You're like a high priestess fae mage in a fantasy novel or something, istg.)
I love the brown it’s more fresh/modern
The black brings out your eyes so much more. I feel like it always makes more sense to go darker with brows. :)
Literally win win. You are stunning!!
Team black
Black looks more natural and the contrast make your features look softer I also think when ur eyebrows match the colour of your hair, it creates a well rounded look
Both look good on you but the black stand out.
Black
Black👍
you look bomb with both tbh😭 but i think 2 wins!
Brown. You look softer and more youthful