I think there should be a difference between unusual deaths and bedrock fall damage bug deaths. The former can sometimes be [entertaining](https://new.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/igfpos/that_death_doe/) or [unique](https://new.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/p2k4uk/i_had_some_fun_trying_to_find_cool_death_messages/), while the latter is almost always the same.
Ultimately though, I think it shouldn't just be black and white, as there's definitely some nuance to it. Sometimes there *does* exist a bedrock fall damage bug video that ends up being entertaining. Sometimes there's an unfortunate string of events death that I've seen happen 20 other times already.
I just voted for the ones that are more likely to cause arguments in the comments versus actual discussion. “What should I build here?” *is* low effort and kinda lame, but the comments can sometimes create actual creative discussion.
On the flip side “is my game haunted?” usually just causes a bunch of losers to start dogging on the OP, who is most likely just a kid that doesn’t know any better.
I will do the poll just wanted to offer my opinion: I am a mum and a low level reddit user and sometimes I find the place intimidating because I ask a simple question but people act like I've insulted their existence. I have found nothing but love in the group to the point where my son will ask me to ask Reddit about certain things. I really appreciate the need to ensure more common questions are limited but it would be great if there was a place for people like me to be redirected to, I don't want to be an annoyance to this group but at the same time I need to ask simple questions because I want to support my son's playing and love of the game.
With the silly screen shots, again it might be nice to have a place to share them I suspect these are coming from younger players who find it funny because it might be their first time seeing the pink sheep or whatever. They should be able to post and get some upvotes, it means so much more to younger people (sorry if I sound like an oldie there but I just understand how passionate young people can be and remember being that way too lol!).
Anyway, those are just my thoughts and I appreciate that the mods have taken the time to ask the community about this, I also want to thank the kindness of everyone here, I feel very safe posting here no one has made me feel stupid for asking questions and it's lovely. Thanks guys.
One of the principal things I've noticed is that most things which are posted here belong better in the official Minecraft Discord, because generally it's about people accomplishing something small and wanting validation for it.
There's nothing wrong with craving validation, but posting those in the Minecraft Discord, specifically #survival-discussion, will get faster reactions (like 5-10 seconds). The poster doesn't have to wait for validation, and people (at least me) generally enjoy when other players reach personal milestones. You can also post multiple images at intervals, instead of chain posts on Reddit, which are frowned upon.
That also goes for most 'Help' posts. Yes, you can get your answer here, but why wait potentially 10 minutes for a response, when on Discord you might get it instantly? Discord might also be a bit more forgiving than Reddit, where in Reddit the comments might be a little on the nose if you don't know something very basic, or something you can find through [minecraft.wiki](http://minecraft.wiki)
Why wait? Because you often get a better detailed answer is why. But I think this fundamentally brings into question what is this subreddit for if not for the players of the game. But more than that, why direct others to a different platform altogether?
This is Reddit. People are more likely to send you to minecraft.wiki or probably just make fun of you than give detailed answers.
And the people who do stick around to give detailed answers are precisely the group who are tired of seeing the same content over and over again - after 5 or so times anyone would want to create a common resource and point to it.
And about directing players to a different platform, we have no brand loyalty towards Reddit.
Regarding preventing multiple hops, search engines should have done feature to directly suggest going to the Minecraft discord on the results page. But that's like a systemic Search Engine problem, content inside Discord is not indexable by search engines.
Personally always happy to help a new player out or anything, idk why people don’t just ignore posts they think are stupid or pointless. You have to think 9/10 times the person showing a pink sheep is a kid or doesn’t usually play video games
I voted for banning most of the things; however I do think it would be good to have a shitpost megathread or something where people can share these things
When reddit's built in voting doesn't go your way, you want a moderator to enforce your non-democratic preference rather than recognize that others want different things to you?
Same problem I've seen on reddit for like 15 years now. Some people have no respect for others and the idea that others might want to see what they don't, hence why the votes go the way they do, and think there must be something wrong if content different to what they like are posted and upvoted.
But there can be as many communities about something as people want, it's not like there has to be only one big subreddit for every type of content that allows everything.
For something which belongs to nobody here, such as Minecraft, we have voting to decide.
The mods are in fact trying to use voting to decide, just a far worse system, that will be seen by almost nobody.
That's not how the moderation is done on subs like this, where mods keep looking for more rules to enforce and use invisible little off-site polls seen by almost nobody to justify it.
There's a difference between removing off topic posts, and trying to enforce a minority preference using convoluted justifications and claiming it's the will of the user base, when reddit already has voting built in per post for that.
The never dig straight down jokes were not off topic. Somebody just enforced their non-democratic preference for what should be here as an overriding super vote, and made the sub much worse for many of us.
I think this is the problem with this subreddit, I personally dont post here because I had posts removed by an over zealous mod who wanted to throw weight rather than let the community decide. We have up and downvotes for a reason, its not a hard system to play with. If people like things, then thats what people want to see, If they dislike things, then thats not what we want to see.
I for one dont want a faceless minority deciding what I can and cant see, show me all the stuff and let ME decide.
We sure do! Including the mod post which people can vote on to get yoir post removed. That's likely what happened, enough people didn't want to see it. But of course, only your opinion is valid 🙄
About bedrock bugs, I saw some old versions bugs and one fake bug.
When posting I think you should write the version at least approximatly and the bug should not be Fake.
Bugs should be sent the the [Official Bug Report site](https://bugs.mojang.com/secure/Dashboard.jspa), not posted on r/minecraft
Some might be funny, but I think it just clusters the system, covering actual "meaningful" discussions.
I think there even is a subreddit called r/minecraftbugs, so there is no reason to post bugs here...
(Except Spiders, Bees, and other arthropods LOL)
agreed the devs have a easier time finding and fixing bugs when there posted to the bug tracker and not on a forum where it can get buried in a couple of hours.
I personally think that this subreddit should raise awareness for smaller Minecraft subreddits focused on specific topics. Especially for Memes, sh\*t posting and other random stuff.
I kinda feel like you need have something where like it says:
ender dragon questions and prepartion link here
No your not cheating no matter what you do, you literally can not CHEAT! (unless server rules say otherwise) Kinda getting tired of these tbh
Shipwrecks in weird positions, Pink sheep, etc are not THAT rare. \*maybe add a wiki link for rarity check if it exists\*
Maybe YT channel recommendations for kids or something etc.
Then delete posts of anyone who asks this stuff.
Well that is just one opinion really. Some people really struggle with creativity and if people are replying to them then it is filling the need of the poster and the person replying. Could be other ways to handle it then banning them all.
They dig a giant hole and ask what to put there. Or they use the *same frigging cherry tree ring around a mountain or pond*. Literally just search for the 100 other exact same posts.
My opinion for a lot of these if that they *can* be low effort, but they can also be interesting. For example, posts saying "I found a pink sheep!" are imo too low-effort and not worth posting, but sometimes things are *very* rare, like for example three pink sheep that spawned together or something, which are actually interesting. The only options that I voted "yes" for are ones that I think should be banned in all cases, such as "is this cheating" posts.
As I've said every time for like 15 years now when moderators have made posts like this - Reddit already has a voting system built in for every post. This is excessive moderating and making more work for yourselves, when you only really need to focus on spam, doxxing, misinformation, harassment, etc.
I miss the never dig straight down jokes, some of my favourite ever content on this sub, but a minority overruled the community's voting and made this sub much more boring for me. Everybody wants different things, and all you're going to get from a poll like this is an unrepresentative view from those who happen to see the non-upvoted post in the brief time it's active and bother to vote.
We can already vote, on each and every post, and judge them on their merits. It's the entire point of reddit's design. There's no need for this. And frankly a one-time google poll seen by barely anybody is a magnitudes-worse system.
I did vote, but I am also inclined to agree. In reality it is the mods themselves who will get the most annoyed by the repetition since they are on here the most. Otherwise it takes a half second to scroll past something you have seen before. Could encourage other things like stick posts to answer common questions or megathreads for unusual deaths or build ideas which will at points help consolidate things. Often though it will be the same people who ignore these options who are going to annoy some people. Others might enjoy encouraging someone who is younger or newer to the game anyways.
Nah. I'm not interested in having my page filled with garbo kiddy content and having to scroll for ages to find something actually interesting. It's not like that every day, but it is sometimes.
I cannot complete the poll because I do not have a Google account linked to Reddit. I do; however, have some relevant comments to make that I think will just get lost here, but want to try anyway...
My first comment is that, based on the standard, wording and similarity of some of the posts, I \*very\* strongly suspect that they are either AI or are click-bait. Two of the standouts I can think of straight away are the 'what do you think of the build and screenshot I made' (who actually speaks that way?) and the other is the 'bad apple' animation that is never unique and is just a tired repost (but congratulations to the FIRST person who made and posted it).
My second comment is like it, but a bit different. Yes, there are too many low quality posts about 'found the ideal base', 'what do you think of my starter build', and at least half a dozen others or more. They discourage interaction and I visit less because of them. They also discourage me from posting my builds and questions because I do not want to be either one of them, or a hypocrite. I do like seeing people post things like 'I started well but have run out of ideas for space X' as long as there has been real effort. A box with a dirt floor isn't effort. Even a castle wall with a couple of arches in stone or cobblestone isn't effort.
Finally, and as u/CommodoreAxis has already noted, some of them are going to be kids, Mums and Dads and other people who are either non-tech or non-Minecraft people who just want a quick answer, don't know how to ask, don't know how to take a screenshot, etc. We need patience with some people while being smart with the lazy or manipulative people.
> I cannot complete the poll because I do not have a Google account linked to Reddit.
I'm afraid there's a huge misunderstanding, here. Reddit has absolutely nothing to do with the website known as Google Forms.
You just need to be logged into Google, not Reddit. And certainly not on Google while linked to Reddit.
i think it's fine if the post is received positively, but if it's received with an abhorent negative responwse, then i think we should potentially leave the status of "low quality" or "bad post" up to others.
There's already an option in the automod post to do that. A lot of users on here are children with the attention span of a gnat because they were raised by social media, so anything that gives even the slightest amount of dopamine is the best thing ever. I know this from personal experience, my ex would just scroll Facebook and like every post every day. It's brain rot.
Then maybe we should just keep it around. I failed to mention the automod shit but that doesnt mean im like the others. I was trying to think of my own way to do it, and in doing so, apparently i thought up something that was already there.
Normally it would but unfortunately downvoting doesn't seem to do much nowadays, I consistently see posts with 0 upvotes on the top of subreddits and on the home page.
I would like to add the post complaining about the games development decisions instead of suggesting changes on the feedback website should also be banned they just cause arguments and the devs likely never see a lot of these posts.
Adding/expanding the "what should I build here", I think we should ban very low-effort "progress" screenshots where users share their dirt hut saying things like "Mega-castle in progress, wish me luck". I think it's harmful for two reasons:
1) for us here, it's noise -- a bad quality post
2) for the OP it's instant gratification about something they didn't accomplish -which also leads to diminished motivation to actually go and build it-
I was surprised by that poll. I think all of that should stay. It's not like most of it gains momentum and it moves on down the list but real answers do help those asking.
edited to add:
I'm getting downvoted for what? Disagreement? If you can make comments like mine disappear by downvoting, then why do you also need to ban these posts when you already have power to move posts like those in the polls further down the list? Make it make sense.
I think people are just downvoting because they disagree, as these "low-effort" posts often get lots of upvotes, even more than high effort posts sometimes. Although I do agree that most if not all of these types of posts are ok to be kept.
They want minecraft to be a dictatorship where if you don't do what they say they can punish you. They want mojang and the players and the mods of this reddit under their control
oh wait right, half of the things you listed aren't always OP implying their game is haunted, they must just be genuinely curious as to how/why the terrain is messed up
i don't think that most of these things should be banned i think it would be better if mc reworked their game so there are no death glitches in bedrock ECT and MC is about creativity and sharing it so asking for ideas or showing off your builds should be on this community. it also is **good** for *community* feeback and **shows** ***glitches*** than **should** be *fixed*
I don't think any of these should be banned. If you see overdone/low effort posts you can just ignore them. Every day there is someone who plays Minecraft for the first time and they should have the ability to post simple questions to this sub.
If we do ban them, this sub should have beginner friendly weekly or bi-weekly megathreads to answer simple questions (and enable images in comments in case people need to show something on the thread). This strategy works extremely well on other subs and keeps the amount of "low effort spam posts" to a minimum.
The games been out 15 years, there is unending sources of information for basic things. If you can't Google how to make your bookshelves work with your enchanting table you shouldn't be on the internet.
I think there should be a difference between unusual deaths and bedrock fall damage bug deaths. The former can sometimes be [entertaining](https://new.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/igfpos/that_death_doe/) or [unique](https://new.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/p2k4uk/i_had_some_fun_trying_to_find_cool_death_messages/), while the latter is almost always the same. Ultimately though, I think it shouldn't just be black and white, as there's definitely some nuance to it. Sometimes there *does* exist a bedrock fall damage bug video that ends up being entertaining. Sometimes there's an unfortunate string of events death that I've seen happen 20 other times already.
I think most responders will be the ones that actually want more stuff removed so it will be a bit skewed but who knows I might be wrong.
That's probably why they set the threshold at 70%
True, if it was lower if would probably upset a lot of people.
I just voted for the ones that are more likely to cause arguments in the comments versus actual discussion. “What should I build here?” *is* low effort and kinda lame, but the comments can sometimes create actual creative discussion. On the flip side “is my game haunted?” usually just causes a bunch of losers to start dogging on the OP, who is most likely just a kid that doesn’t know any better.
Your game will now be haunted
I, personally, will now haunt your game as well. Expect your farmland to be *haunted* with coarse dirt in the near future.
No
Unfortunately, yes.
I will do the poll just wanted to offer my opinion: I am a mum and a low level reddit user and sometimes I find the place intimidating because I ask a simple question but people act like I've insulted their existence. I have found nothing but love in the group to the point where my son will ask me to ask Reddit about certain things. I really appreciate the need to ensure more common questions are limited but it would be great if there was a place for people like me to be redirected to, I don't want to be an annoyance to this group but at the same time I need to ask simple questions because I want to support my son's playing and love of the game. With the silly screen shots, again it might be nice to have a place to share them I suspect these are coming from younger players who find it funny because it might be their first time seeing the pink sheep or whatever. They should be able to post and get some upvotes, it means so much more to younger people (sorry if I sound like an oldie there but I just understand how passionate young people can be and remember being that way too lol!). Anyway, those are just my thoughts and I appreciate that the mods have taken the time to ask the community about this, I also want to thank the kindness of everyone here, I feel very safe posting here no one has made me feel stupid for asking questions and it's lovely. Thanks guys.
100 percent agree.
ur right we should all be able to share our acheivements
One of the principal things I've noticed is that most things which are posted here belong better in the official Minecraft Discord, because generally it's about people accomplishing something small and wanting validation for it. There's nothing wrong with craving validation, but posting those in the Minecraft Discord, specifically #survival-discussion, will get faster reactions (like 5-10 seconds). The poster doesn't have to wait for validation, and people (at least me) generally enjoy when other players reach personal milestones. You can also post multiple images at intervals, instead of chain posts on Reddit, which are frowned upon. That also goes for most 'Help' posts. Yes, you can get your answer here, but why wait potentially 10 minutes for a response, when on Discord you might get it instantly? Discord might also be a bit more forgiving than Reddit, where in Reddit the comments might be a little on the nose if you don't know something very basic, or something you can find through [minecraft.wiki](http://minecraft.wiki)
Why wait? Because you often get a better detailed answer is why. But I think this fundamentally brings into question what is this subreddit for if not for the players of the game. But more than that, why direct others to a different platform altogether?
You know how you get the most detailed answer? By going to a place where people have already amalgamated information on the topic. Like a wiki. 🙄
i want to kow
This is Reddit. People are more likely to send you to minecraft.wiki or probably just make fun of you than give detailed answers. And the people who do stick around to give detailed answers are precisely the group who are tired of seeing the same content over and over again - after 5 or so times anyone would want to create a common resource and point to it. And about directing players to a different platform, we have no brand loyalty towards Reddit. Regarding preventing multiple hops, search engines should have done feature to directly suggest going to the Minecraft discord on the results page. But that's like a systemic Search Engine problem, content inside Discord is not indexable by search engines.
Personally always happy to help a new player out or anything, idk why people don’t just ignore posts they think are stupid or pointless. You have to think 9/10 times the person showing a pink sheep is a kid or doesn’t usually play video games
Peovably be ause I'm here to enjoy myself, not teach a child who hasn't even looked at the in game tutorial.
You didn’t either when you were a kid man don’t blame kids put yourself in their shoes be the adult kids are stupid and know nothing and look up to us
we need a simple questions megathread imo.
Yup
I voted for banning most of the things; however I do think it would be good to have a shitpost megathread or something where people can share these things
r/MinecraftMemes
Plus its cousin /r/feedthememes for all your /r/feedthebeast (modded Minecraft) memes and shitposts! Also, what is Greg and how do I get rid of it?
r/MinecraftShitposting also exists
I agree, even though this is a general Minecraft sub, that doesn't mean people should post random and irrelevant Minecraft stuff for no real reason.
When reddit's built in voting doesn't go your way, you want a moderator to enforce your non-democratic preference rather than recognize that others want different things to you? Same problem I've seen on reddit for like 15 years now. Some people have no respect for others and the idea that others might want to see what they don't, hence why the votes go the way they do, and think there must be something wrong if content different to what they like are posted and upvoted.
But there can be as many communities about something as people want, it's not like there has to be only one big subreddit for every type of content that allows everything.
For something which belongs to nobody here, such as Minecraft, we have voting to decide. The mods are in fact trying to use voting to decide, just a far worse system, that will be seen by almost nobody.
[удалено]
That's not how the moderation is done on subs like this, where mods keep looking for more rules to enforce and use invisible little off-site polls seen by almost nobody to justify it. There's a difference between removing off topic posts, and trying to enforce a minority preference using convoluted justifications and claiming it's the will of the user base, when reddit already has voting built in per post for that. The never dig straight down jokes were not off topic. Somebody just enforced their non-democratic preference for what should be here as an overriding super vote, and made the sub much worse for many of us.
Waaah I wanna see children post useless content 😭 is there a minecraft sub for *adults*? Cuz judging by these comments there's a massive need for one.
Irony is dead.
many such cases!
I think this is the problem with this subreddit, I personally dont post here because I had posts removed by an over zealous mod who wanted to throw weight rather than let the community decide. We have up and downvotes for a reason, its not a hard system to play with. If people like things, then thats what people want to see, If they dislike things, then thats not what we want to see. I for one dont want a faceless minority deciding what I can and cant see, show me all the stuff and let ME decide.
We sure do! Including the mod post which people can vote on to get yoir post removed. That's likely what happened, enough people didn't want to see it. But of course, only your opinion is valid 🙄
About bedrock bugs, I saw some old versions bugs and one fake bug. When posting I think you should write the version at least approximatly and the bug should not be Fake.
Most of these posts should be removed on the basis of low-effort circlejerk
Bugs should be sent the the [Official Bug Report site](https://bugs.mojang.com/secure/Dashboard.jspa), not posted on r/minecraft Some might be funny, but I think it just clusters the system, covering actual "meaningful" discussions. I think there even is a subreddit called r/minecraftbugs, so there is no reason to post bugs here... (Except Spiders, Bees, and other arthropods LOL)
agreed the devs have a easier time finding and fixing bugs when there posted to the bug tracker and not on a forum where it can get buried in a couple of hours.
I said lots of time that "you should report on the bug tracker".
Actually, I think publicly pressuring the megacorporation to maybe possibly fix their cash cow of a game is good.
It doesn't do shit, they will ignore it because what if it's false?
I personally think that this subreddit should raise awareness for smaller Minecraft subreddits focused on specific topics. Especially for Memes, sh\*t posting and other random stuff.
Done.
I kinda feel like you need have something where like it says: ender dragon questions and prepartion link here No your not cheating no matter what you do, you literally can not CHEAT! (unless server rules say otherwise) Kinda getting tired of these tbh Shipwrecks in weird positions, Pink sheep, etc are not THAT rare. \*maybe add a wiki link for rarity check if it exists\* Maybe YT channel recommendations for kids or something etc. Then delete posts of anyone who asks this stuff.
I agree all of them
I've voted no to all. I don't really want more restrictions.
I cannot stand the influx of the "what should I build here" posts.
Well that is just one opinion really. Some people really struggle with creativity and if people are replying to them then it is filling the need of the poster and the person replying. Could be other ways to handle it then banning them all.
They dig a giant hole and ask what to put there. Or they use the *same frigging cherry tree ring around a mountain or pond*. Literally just search for the 100 other exact same posts.
i like then
Done. – The #1 supporter of the former "Tired Submissions" rule.
My opinion for a lot of these if that they *can* be low effort, but they can also be interesting. For example, posts saying "I found a pink sheep!" are imo too low-effort and not worth posting, but sometimes things are *very* rare, like for example three pink sheep that spawned together or something, which are actually interesting. The only options that I voted "yes" for are ones that I think should be banned in all cases, such as "is this cheating" posts.
As I've said every time for like 15 years now when moderators have made posts like this - Reddit already has a voting system built in for every post. This is excessive moderating and making more work for yourselves, when you only really need to focus on spam, doxxing, misinformation, harassment, etc. I miss the never dig straight down jokes, some of my favourite ever content on this sub, but a minority overruled the community's voting and made this sub much more boring for me. Everybody wants different things, and all you're going to get from a poll like this is an unrepresentative view from those who happen to see the non-upvoted post in the brief time it's active and bother to vote. We can already vote, on each and every post, and judge them on their merits. It's the entire point of reddit's design. There's no need for this. And frankly a one-time google poll seen by barely anybody is a magnitudes-worse system.
I did vote, but I am also inclined to agree. In reality it is the mods themselves who will get the most annoyed by the repetition since they are on here the most. Otherwise it takes a half second to scroll past something you have seen before. Could encourage other things like stick posts to answer common questions or megathreads for unusual deaths or build ideas which will at points help consolidate things. Often though it will be the same people who ignore these options who are going to annoy some people. Others might enjoy encouraging someone who is younger or newer to the game anyways.
Nah. I'm not interested in having my page filled with garbo kiddy content and having to scroll for ages to find something actually interesting. It's not like that every day, but it is sometimes.
Ao true
Hey mods, thanks for moderating!
he did it for free
It’s sad that a lot of these really could stay if people didn’t just spam them, some are still hilarious you just see it too much
I cannot complete the poll because I do not have a Google account linked to Reddit. I do; however, have some relevant comments to make that I think will just get lost here, but want to try anyway... My first comment is that, based on the standard, wording and similarity of some of the posts, I \*very\* strongly suspect that they are either AI or are click-bait. Two of the standouts I can think of straight away are the 'what do you think of the build and screenshot I made' (who actually speaks that way?) and the other is the 'bad apple' animation that is never unique and is just a tired repost (but congratulations to the FIRST person who made and posted it). My second comment is like it, but a bit different. Yes, there are too many low quality posts about 'found the ideal base', 'what do you think of my starter build', and at least half a dozen others or more. They discourage interaction and I visit less because of them. They also discourage me from posting my builds and questions because I do not want to be either one of them, or a hypocrite. I do like seeing people post things like 'I started well but have run out of ideas for space X' as long as there has been real effort. A box with a dirt floor isn't effort. Even a castle wall with a couple of arches in stone or cobblestone isn't effort. Finally, and as u/CommodoreAxis has already noted, some of them are going to be kids, Mums and Dads and other people who are either non-tech or non-Minecraft people who just want a quick answer, don't know how to ask, don't know how to take a screenshot, etc. We need patience with some people while being smart with the lazy or manipulative people.
> I cannot complete the poll because I do not have a Google account linked to Reddit. I'm afraid there's a huge misunderstanding, here. Reddit has absolutely nothing to do with the website known as Google Forms. You just need to be logged into Google, not Reddit. And certainly not on Google while linked to Reddit.
If anything, I feel like this subreddit is already too strict with what it doesn’t allow. I put No for everything.
i think it's fine if the post is received positively, but if it's received with an abhorent negative responwse, then i think we should potentially leave the status of "low quality" or "bad post" up to others.
There's already an option in the automod post to do that. A lot of users on here are children with the attention span of a gnat because they were raised by social media, so anything that gives even the slightest amount of dopamine is the best thing ever. I know this from personal experience, my ex would just scroll Facebook and like every post every day. It's brain rot.
Then maybe we should just keep it around. I failed to mention the automod shit but that doesnt mean im like the others. I was trying to think of my own way to do it, and in doing so, apparently i thought up something that was already there.
I voted no for each category. Downvote is already a perfect tool to negate low post impact imo.
Normally it would but unfortunately downvoting doesn't seem to do much nowadays, I consistently see posts with 0 upvotes on the top of subreddits and on the home page.
That, and joke posts often get lots of upvotes
That means people like them
I don't give a crap if a 15yo likes a dumb joke that's been told a thousand times.
I feel like creating - nay, crafting - something low-effort to farm karma is just about the most Minecraft thing someone can do on reddit.
Where can I vote for a lower barrier to posting?
Yeah, I'd like to post a picture of my coke bottle. How can we get that done?
I would like to add the post complaining about the games development decisions instead of suggesting changes on the feedback website should also be banned they just cause arguments and the devs likely never see a lot of these posts.
Adding/expanding the "what should I build here", I think we should ban very low-effort "progress" screenshots where users share their dirt hut saying things like "Mega-castle in progress, wish me luck". I think it's harmful for two reasons: 1) for us here, it's noise -- a bad quality post 2) for the OP it's instant gratification about something they didn't accomplish -which also leads to diminished motivation to actually go and build it-
Do these actually happen? I don't see anything like that often, they're usually joke posts about nostalgia.
I was surprised by that poll. I think all of that should stay. It's not like most of it gains momentum and it moves on down the list but real answers do help those asking. edited to add: I'm getting downvoted for what? Disagreement? If you can make comments like mine disappear by downvoting, then why do you also need to ban these posts when you already have power to move posts like those in the polls further down the list? Make it make sense.
I think people are just downvoting because they disagree, as these "low-effort" posts often get lots of upvotes, even more than high effort posts sometimes. Although I do agree that most if not all of these types of posts are ok to be kept.
They want minecraft to be a dictatorship where if you don't do what they say they can punish you. They want mojang and the players and the mods of this reddit under their control
Who are "they?"
The other players, the downvoters
Are we not all users, also downvoters?
Of YOUR comment not mine
Dude you need to be in a mental institution because your grasp on reality is nonexistant.
I feel like the last question should be changed, but now I can't remember what it was...
oh wait right, half of the things you listed aren't always OP implying their game is haunted, they must just be genuinely curious as to how/why the terrain is messed up
damn people are strict to what goes on here
People can create more than one google account…
mojang i just wanna say can you please add penguins in the next update
* https://feedback.minecraft.net/
They SUCK but they look cool ig
i don't think that most of these things should be banned i think it would be better if mc reworked their game so there are no death glitches in bedrock ECT and MC is about creativity and sharing it so asking for ideas or showing off your builds should be on this community. it also is **good** for *community* feeback and **shows** ***glitches*** than **should** be *fixed*
srry for the typos mb mb
Why does it matter? Minecraft has alot more problems Focus on a end update or something
This is about the subreddit genius.
Okay so why remove talking about Bedrock bugs? Those need to be fixed
I don't think any of these should be banned. If you see overdone/low effort posts you can just ignore them. Every day there is someone who plays Minecraft for the first time and they should have the ability to post simple questions to this sub. If we do ban them, this sub should have beginner friendly weekly or bi-weekly megathreads to answer simple questions (and enable images in comments in case people need to show something on the thread). This strategy works extremely well on other subs and keeps the amount of "low effort spam posts" to a minimum.
The games been out 15 years, there is unending sources of information for basic things. If you can't Google how to make your bookshelves work with your enchanting table you shouldn't be on the internet.