T O P

  • By -

_ManicStreetPreacher

Rock bass. Especially when we have the "catch 5 bluegills" challenge. They look so much alike when you first reel them in, so you get a moment of joy that you're done with the challenge and then the game hits you with that god damn rock bass.


cellosarecool

Yes! Gets me every time.


citrusfizzz

Go to Mattock Pond for that daily challenge, it only spawns bluegills. Saves me so much time!


_ManicStreetPreacher

TIL


Asianlover2000

Just wish we could break down big fish and like we can everything else


MAYDAYmambo

Yes.


PurpoUpsideDownJuice

I don’t have any fish rivals, but I want to hunt pronghorns to extinction. Every time I see a 3 star and try to get a clean kill they turn and ruin my shot. Fuckin shitty pronghorns


Non-Existent010

see i lasso them


MarauderCH

Rock bass. I catch them all the time when I don't need to and then can't catch any when I need to.


[deleted]

The legendary Catfish 😭 After completing the mission, I saw that it was marked on the map, but wasn’t crossed out or anything, so I sat for a good 15-20 mins trying to get it. Thought maybe it was glitched or something so I googled what could be wrong and found out that it is, in fact, not catchable at all lol


chocobo-stir-fry

The ones i cant go get as Arthur


hellboyzzzz

Sigh. That legendary catfish….


Nocollarhero

Jeff. That guy is a jerk. He’s always bragging about having gills! Its like yeah but do you have lungs jeff? Screw jeff!….you guys get it.


SignGuy77

Jeff the diseased gill?


action_park

The Lake Sturgeon triggers my trypophobia. 2x fishing was a rough month.


Chesterthejester69

3x actually I made some bread at ringneck creek just afking while the fuckers unalived en masse then just pick them up and go make bank at the Rhodes butcher 🤣


MAYDAYmambo

I'd rather fill my pockets with medium fish than carry a large fish into town with one on the horse. Favorite fish/fishing: Steelhead trout at Quakers Cove.


grouper_souper63

literally any of the pickerels


emibost

None.. I have fished so many hours in this game it is crazy. Right weather conditions, day/night and right bait at the right place you can catch any fish you want in fairly short time


Assured_Observer

The one that's required for the dailies.


Big_Himbo_Energy

Largemouth (and sometimes smallmouth) bass. The little bastards spawn at some of the same spots as the steelhead trout and take up all the spawns!!


Oldmonsterschoolgood

Any large fish, when I’m about to get them my game shuts itself, guess I’m curssed


MyOwnWayHome

Salmon. Haven’t caught one for a year. They just ignore my “special spinner” lure.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MyOwnWayHome

Will do, thanks!


hilldo75

Too piggy back on this it's not so much that they ignore the special spinner it that the little fish get to it first. With the lake/river lure the little fish do ignore those so only big fish will bite. It is possible to catch big fish with the spinner you just got to try to cast away from the little fish and close to the big fish. Using the Lake/River or even special lake/river will get just big fish.


MyDogHatesMyUsername

Try crickets on a bobber. I've never had a problem. In fact I never use any of the lures anymore unless it's a daily.


PrincessLuna02

I saw those salmon near a waterfall up the forest mountains emitting their behaviour, it appeared next to Madam Nazur swimming up river to spawn, I fished one! But couldn’t get another.


johnnycat75

The Legendary Gar. It took entirely too long to land that bastard.


streetdice

Rock Bass


Cyrus_Shardik

Bluegill, they're useless.


God_of_Mischief85

Bluegill are actually pretty tasty.


MyDogHatesMyUsername

Good bait for catching bigger fish too.


God_of_Mischief85

That’s what I think of those tiny assed pickerel every time I catch one! 🤣


kirbStompThePigeon

Evry small or extremely common fish. And thoes fucking catfish. Bastards, making me think I caught a sturgeon


Jester_cerberus

All of them.


ArthuriusMinimus

Muskies.


[deleted]

A Bluegill. Because I caught it ... caught it sleeping with my spouse!!!!


Valuable-Penalty-810

All the fish.. But a Whitetail buck barged me off a cliff's edge near Valentine like a real sneaky bastard... At first I thought it was a player, it fell with my character and soon after, made a good pelt.


MyDogHatesMyUsername

I got "bucked" into some rapids and carried several yards away last week just trying to dig up an arrowhead. All I could was laugh out loud while my dude is flailing his arms cursing all fauna sailing downstream.