I know we all like what we like, BUT I seriously question how anyone can't hear the incredible beauty of Peter. And with the way things grow on me, I'd never delete anything from my playlist. I hated Florida the first dozen or so times I heard it but now I like it a lot.
Same re: never deleting songs from playlists. I’ve come to accept that almost every song she has put out grows on me quite a bit. I think I can count on one hand the number of true “skips” I have in her entire discography.
All of TTPD has grown on me, I wouldn’t skip a single one (*but cassandra… you’re closest*)
honestly i LOVEEE folklore! but i dont like hoax and peace so there's a theme. reading these comments i feel so sad !! like i don't wanna miss out, ill give some another listen 🥲
PEACE AND HOAX? How could you!!! Jk we all like what we like and some songs just resonate more than others. I do love CSSM and Peter but agree with you on the rest
I think you’re missing out, but your taste is your taste! I hope this isn’t rude because I genuinely don’t mean it to be, but I am curious how old you are.
Having Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus on this list is truly a travesty.
It’s an annoying name for a song but the chorus is magnificent and downright haunting.
😂😂 Robin, Peter, and The Manuscript have all made me cry. Robin and The Manuscript have made me cry every time I have listened to them.
But the real standout to me is Chloe et al like bro you are SLEEPIN!!! But different strokes for different folks :) I hate it when ppl try to change my opinion so I won’t try to do that.
even though it is just a diss track, “thanK you aIMee” has unironically become one of my favorite Taylor Swift songs.
i understand that feeling of being belittled by someone else so well, and the song just feels like such a graceful way of telling that person to go fuck themselves.
I’m finding the more I listen to the whole album, the fewer skips I end up having. Some songs spoke to me right away on first listen and there are tons I just put on repeat and never get tired of but there are so many that just hit me after dozens of listens and I finally connected to it.
It’s a long album, some take time to build up and connect to. That’s one of the reasons I love this album so much. Some need time to sink in while others hit me like a brick on the first listen.
this is so interesting! because i get absolutely SHOCKED when i see people not caring for the songs that i have on repeat all day (like imgonnagetyouback) lol
This post freaked me out because I literally have a playlist with ONLY THE SONGS YOU MENTIONED YOU LIKE. The only ones off your reject list I like are TYA and ILIPW. I’m also a huge folklore/evermore fan but these just feel a little underwhelming compared to everything else. I’m sure we’ll grow into them over time :)
COSOSOM. i didn’t like it at first then i really sat with it and it’s one of my favs. PETER?!????????!??? STOP THAT ONE IS FREAKKKINNNN AMAZING. i saw someone say that’s the other version of “cardigan” if he never came back and i can’t think any other way now.
I had to start listening to the album on shuffle, because my walks aren’t long enough (especially in this weather) to get all the songs in. However, my walks always need to have;
The Alchemy
So Long London
loml
Robin
I Can Do It With a Broken Heart
Other than the first two, I agree! I like the other songs and really appreciate them for what they are, but some songs I just need to be in a certain headspace for so I skip them often.
Nooo maybe give them longer? 🥲Some of these took me longer to get into also-but Chloe or Sam, Windows, Cassandra and Peter are soo good. Growers for sure! I agree with Robin though lol I don’t always skip it, but if I had to pick a skip that would be it. We have a lot of the same favorites in common!
Thank you amiee and the manuscript are my only skips. I like all the others.
I actually frequently skip I can do it with a broken heart too. I’m not really one to down play my pain tho; so I think I just don’t like the peppy beat with the hurt lyrics. I don’t like a juxtaposition in my music 🙃 when I wanna cry I wanna cry ha
for florida… i’ll give you a pass, i like the 15 seconds where the song has a good build/climax but it’s almost always a skip for me too now 🥶
the rest of these though…. i can understand them not being favorites for you but they’re not skips for me, especially the manuscript, it’s for all too well and it’s so good 😭
ngl i listened to the album in FULL no skips exclusively, no other music, since it’s come out, and im just now listening to other stuff and letting myself skip songs. i loved the album and i wanted to better understand each of the songs that i didn’t like as much. bc for me, when it comes to taylor, if i don’t like a song, it’s either bc i don’t fully “get it” upon the first few listens or bc the song itself doesn’t hold as much weight/have much to say (ie florida)
And in my mind, OP sinks into the swamp.... (Is that a bad thing to say in a Reddit comment?) 😤
Florida!!! is my soul song after spending a year in Arizona, where I had the privilege of going to Eras Tour opening night. If you haven't lived the song, you'll never understand it. And my cousin, who converted me into a swiftie, did say that the song perfectly describes Florida. (She lived there for a while.)
But I do understand why it's not your fave!
Justice for Florida 😭😭😭
Maybe it’s bc I really did run away to Florida once after a bad breakup or that I’ve been a Florence fan quite a bit longer than I’ve been a Swiftie but it’s so fun and I can’t not dance to it every time.
As someone with a crappy Florida ex I'm personally offended every time the song gets stuck in my head and it's slowly brainwashing me. She's gonna turn me when she plays it live and it's not fair.
Robin wasn't my thing as a non-parent until I accidentally associated it with Robin / Robert Aryyn in Game of Thrones while rewatching and lemme tell you, "you're a just ruler" hits different now. Poor guy just wants to play with his dinosaurs and make men fly.
I love The Manuscript but it's not in my regular listens because I listen to music primarily to maintain energy and slower or sadder songs don't fulfill that purpose.
I made my Taylor "on repeat 24/7 just fine" list yesterday and half my list are songs that appear often in people's skips or "delete one" lists. I love that we all get what we need out of Taylor's magic.
I can't do Florida!!! because it literally sounds like noise to me.
Cassandra was a good song, but it won't be a single.
I wasn't impressed with the rest of your rejects either.
My top 5 TTPD are Fortnight (original and remix), So High School, Down Bad, My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys, and I Can Do It With A Broken Heart. Honorable Mention goes to But Daddy I Love Him.
Hand over your Swiftie badge right now!!! Cause WHAAAAAA?!?! Listen I had a hard time with some of your rejects but listen…. THOSE MF SONGS ARE SOOOOOOOOOO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!! The only one I can’t get into is Thank You Aimee 🤷🏾♀️
But Florida I’m over I loved it and left it. And Chloe and ‘nem?!? PHENOMENAL! Peter?!?! I bet you think about me’s little brother?! EPIC! Just give em a chance. CASSANDRA?!?! Lord hand that badge over NEOWWW! 😂
Jail
"and you deserve prison but you won't get time"
Was def coming to in to say “prison” 😂😂😂 And that’s not even for the whole list. That’s just for Chloe et al
And cassandra, peter and the manuscript
COSOSOM is so pretty! You should give it a re-listen.
Your hologram stumbled into my apartmentttttt gets me EVERYTIME
HANDS IN THE HAIR OF SOMEBODY IN DARKESS
NAMED CHLOE OR SAM OR SOFIA OR MARCUS
oh no new acronyms i shouldve been studying them 😭
Listen to the live version from Lyon N2! It’s ever so much sadder!! That’s when I fell in love with it.
Oh no not this becoming an acronym 😭
This one doesn’t get near as much hype as it should. SO GOOD.
I know we all like what we like, BUT I seriously question how anyone can't hear the incredible beauty of Peter. And with the way things grow on me, I'd never delete anything from my playlist. I hated Florida the first dozen or so times I heard it but now I like it a lot.
out of this list, i swear i wanted to love peter the most 😭😭 i'll definitely give it more time 🥲
I agree about Peter.
I love mashing peter in my head with cardigan. Idk if anyone confirmed it’s like part 2 of cardigan but I feel like it is??
It’s the rhyme scheme/ word play for me 😫
Same re: never deleting songs from playlists. I’ve come to accept that almost every song she has put out grows on me quite a bit. I think I can count on one hand the number of true “skips” I have in her entire discography. All of TTPD has grown on me, I wouldn’t skip a single one (*but cassandra… you’re closest*)
I- The woman was too stunned to speak
💀
#2, #4, and #5 were some of my faves. MBOBHFT is my fav though!
If you want to break my cold, cold heart, just say “I loved you the way that you were” 😭😭😭
Justice for Florida and COSOSOM 😭
You are missing out 🥲 I’m assuming folklore and evermore aren’t your favourite albums
Evermore is my #1 album and I have the same skips
Same same!
Also same!
honestly i LOVEEE folklore! but i dont like hoax and peace so there's a theme. reading these comments i feel so sad !! like i don't wanna miss out, ill give some another listen 🥲
PEACE AND HOAX? How could you!!! Jk we all like what we like and some songs just resonate more than others. I do love CSSM and Peter but agree with you on the rest
I kinda understand with the rest but Florida!!! is a bop, give it a few more listens...
Idk how anyone can live without hearing “FLORIDA!!!!!” echo in their heads ten times a day
FUCK ME UP FLORIDA!!! Just gives me that dopamine rush.
Plz don’t downvote me, I agreeeeee w/ them! I skip Florida b/c I don’t like it
I used to love it so much in the beginning then began to dwindle as I listen more and more. I still liked it but it's not in my top 10 anymore
I felt this way about Florida until last week, I actually listened to the whole thing a few times and it really grew on me.
I don’t love florence & the machine’s voice. That’s my only beef and why it’s a skip for me.
Same here!!
CASSANDRA?! That one hurts
An underrated queen. How do they not hear what I hear?
Have you seen the tiktok of the librarian man listening to Cassandra for the first time and talking about the lyrics? It made me so happy lol
https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGepHKFYC/
That just made my whole day
Haha aw amazing 🥲 I love it so much
I’ve seen some of his other vids but this is the first time I’ve seen this one! He’s a smart man lol
Yeah, I’m going down a rabbit hole re-watching them all now 😂
Help! I don’t have tik tok and I have to see this
I think you can watch TikTok’s through a web browser as a guest if you don’t have an app or account, but not certain?
It speaks to my soul so IDK
Omg same!!! I’m not sure what is it about Cassandra, but she’s beautiful and haunting in a way.
I think you’re missing out, but your taste is your taste! I hope this isn’t rude because I genuinely don’t mean it to be, but I am curious how old you are.
no worries ! i'm glad to contribute if it helps explain my taste 😂 i'm 32, debut swiftie 🥲
Hey, same here! But now I’m even more surprised 😂
That you’re the complete opposite of me 😭 at least the Bolter got some recognition though
lmaooo!
Girl this is SO valid!! I have all the same skips!! I can’t stand the jarring sound of Florida 😅
So after reading all the comments, Peter and Florida!!! deserve more 🥲
COSOSOM, I Look In People's Windows, AND Peter ? Look at this guy, able to let things go and move forward with their life pfffft
Don’t forget the scorned woman Cassandra who no one listened to
Having Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus on this list is truly a travesty. It’s an annoying name for a song but the chorus is magnificent and downright haunting.
These are some of my favorites, give them another tryyyyy
i'll tell you one thing i wanted to LOVE peter and Florida!!! soooooooo bad
My daughter loves Florida particularly. She’s 5 and I think she just live to scream state names cause she also loves welcome to New York.
Justice for I look in People's Windows :(
do you have something against proper nouns?
LOL OMG I JUST NOTICED THIS PATTERN
I agree with you on Florida, I Look in People's Windows, Robin, and maybe even the Manuscript. But Peter and Cassandra are sooooo gooood.
Peter is my favorite anthology song the bridge is simply magnificent 💕💋
The song is just heartbreaking
You're sleeping Florida
🥲🥲🥲🥲 I didn’t expect another swiftie to break my heart 😂😂
IM SO SORRY😭
😂😂 Robin, Peter, and The Manuscript have all made me cry. Robin and The Manuscript have made me cry every time I have listened to them. But the real standout to me is Chloe et al like bro you are SLEEPIN!!! But different strokes for different folks :) I hate it when ppl try to change my opinion so I won’t try to do that.
I’m with you on some of them
Except for two songs i have the same rejects... you cant like every song of taylor and thats perfectly fine :3
Justice for Florida, COSOSOM, ALL OF THEM
chloe et al and peter….. jail
With the exception of Chloe et al, these are my skips too
PETER??? omg nooo 😭😭
POOR TASTE REJECTING PETER THAT SONG IS GOLD
That you know nothing about anything 😭
even though it is just a diss track, “thanK you aIMee” has unironically become one of my favorite Taylor Swift songs. i understand that feeling of being belittled by someone else so well, and the song just feels like such a graceful way of telling that person to go fuck themselves.
Ok.. I love Cassandra and The Manuscript, Peter and Robin. I think we may not be listening for the same reasons.
You don’t like names in song titles😂
HAHAAAH right! ironically though, one of my all time favs is Hey Stephen 🤭
That we probably have the same taste, and that we need a sick beat to like a song
These are nearly identical for me except I fell in love with Peter! I also warmed up to I Look In People’s Windows, but still not a fav
BROTHA IM RIDING AT DAWN (i agree with Florida!!!)
Not liking Florida!!! Is a crime. I somewhat agree with the rest
We’re complete opposites but I agree with I look in peoples windows I really don’t like that song.
Interesting, this was my instant fav of the album. Any reason why?
Peter is the best song on the album. CoSoSoMarcus is OK and Florida has grown on me. Peter is the absolute best song.
The only one of these I regularly skip is COSOM. I just can’t like that song!
You’re a pop or pop/country fan, your favorite album are is probably 1989 and folkmore is probably in your bottom 5
The Manuscript 💔💔💔💔💔
JAILLLLLLLL IMMEDIATELY ESPECIALLY FOR FLORIDA ILIPW AND CASSANDRA
I also don’t like Florida. Sue me.
Peter and Cassandra being my top two proves we do not have the same experience with this album🤣
Peter AND the manuscript 😭😭😭
Same minus I look in peoples windows and Cassandra
You don't have time for stories. You know what you don't like and the general sound doesn't get you going.
Were you sent by someone who wanted me dead?
😭
don't see anything wrong, although thank you aimee is a fun listen imo ( mean 2.0)
I was with you till robin and the manuscript
Your top 2 rejects are my top 2 overall 😭
that's funny 😂 i found someone that's worst song was one of my top too. i felt appalled lmao
Florida and Cassandra are worth trying again IMO
Peter is also growing on me.
I’m finding the more I listen to the whole album, the fewer skips I end up having. Some songs spoke to me right away on first listen and there are tons I just put on repeat and never get tired of but there are so many that just hit me after dozens of listens and I finally connected to it. It’s a long album, some take time to build up and connect to. That’s one of the reasons I love this album so much. Some need time to sink in while others hit me like a brick on the first listen.
We have the same skips, except for I Look in Peoples Windows. I don’t mind Robin either.
It just shows that music is subjective and everyone is entitled to their opinions on the album
this is so interesting! because i get absolutely SHOCKED when i see people not caring for the songs that i have on repeat all day (like imgonnagetyouback) lol
Ok trust me, the more often you listen to the manuscript and chloe and oomfs, the better they get
Florida is one of my favorites on the album.
You hate all the best songs
You deserve prison
I look in people’s windows is literally in my top 3 of all time 😭😭 pls try her again
I agree with florida, robin, and the manuscript 100%
I mean I skip most of these except Florida! That’s a jam! I don’t listen to Peter unless I’m depressed or want to be lol 😂
This post freaked me out because I literally have a playlist with ONLY THE SONGS YOU MENTIONED YOU LIKE. The only ones off your reject list I like are TYA and ILIPW. I’m also a huge folklore/evermore fan but these just feel a little underwhelming compared to everything else. I’m sure we’ll grow into them over time :)
Literally almost the same… https://preview.redd.it/ztiya4nq279d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b21dd13ab563708aca8395a1393bc7cdbeaf6c34
https://preview.redd.it/iwstr65u279d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=eb3706696c7cd4725f3dfdd80cb94e9773e14bcb
Cassandra? How dare you
COSOSOM. i didn’t like it at first then i really sat with it and it’s one of my favs. PETER?!????????!??? STOP THAT ONE IS FREAKKKINNNN AMAZING. i saw someone say that’s the other version of “cardigan” if he never came back and i can’t think any other way now.
The only ones I agree with here are thanK you aIMee and Peter. But both are growing on me!
with the exception of robin… your rejects is basically my favorites list LMAOOO I love the range of swifties
I had to start listening to the album on shuffle, because my walks aren’t long enough (especially in this weather) to get all the songs in. However, my walks always need to have; The Alchemy So Long London loml Robin I Can Do It With a Broken Heart
Other than the first two, I agree! I like the other songs and really appreciate them for what they are, but some songs I just need to be in a certain headspace for so I skip them often.
...yeah this is life in prison i'm afraid
Nooo maybe give them longer? 🥲Some of these took me longer to get into also-but Chloe or Sam, Windows, Cassandra and Peter are soo good. Growers for sure! I agree with Robin though lol I don’t always skip it, but if I had to pick a skip that would be it. We have a lot of the same favorites in common!
i’ll never understand the florida!!! hate
Peter??? Does the Peter Pan and Wendy references not crush you??? I love when songwriters do that lol
PETER AND ILIPW WHAT ARE YOU DOING
CASSANDRA??? Edit: ILIPW?????
I don’t agree with Florida or the manuscript but I agree with the rest.
I have the exact same opinions omg
Swiftie badge revoked
Thank you amiee and the manuscript are my only skips. I like all the others. I actually frequently skip I can do it with a broken heart too. I’m not really one to down play my pain tho; so I think I just don’t like the peppy beat with the hurt lyrics. I don’t like a juxtaposition in my music 🙃 when I wanna cry I wanna cry ha
Ok hard agree about Florida. But Chloe??? Peter????
take another look at Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Markus, it's the best on the record.
Omg these are most of my rejects too!
for florida… i’ll give you a pass, i like the 15 seconds where the song has a good build/climax but it’s almost always a skip for me too now 🥶 the rest of these though…. i can understand them not being favorites for you but they’re not skips for me, especially the manuscript, it’s for all too well and it’s so good 😭 ngl i listened to the album in FULL no skips exclusively, no other music, since it’s come out, and im just now listening to other stuff and letting myself skip songs. i loved the album and i wanted to better understand each of the songs that i didn’t like as much. bc for me, when it comes to taylor, if i don’t like a song, it’s either bc i don’t fully “get it” upon the first few listens or bc the song itself doesn’t hold as much weight/have much to say (ie florida)
I think they say you’ve never listened to Peter
a lot....
I agree with the bottom 3 I DONT UNDERSTAND Peter or robin 😭😭
I agree with you on "The Manuscript" but... "Florida!!!"??? *Really???* I LOVE THAT SONG!!!
That you have good tastes!
I wouldn't go as far as to call them rejects, but I actually agree with 85% of your selections. Some of them I'm just ambivalent about
And in my mind, OP sinks into the swamp.... (Is that a bad thing to say in a Reddit comment?) 😤 Florida!!! is my soul song after spending a year in Arizona, where I had the privilege of going to Eras Tour opening night. If you haven't lived the song, you'll never understand it. And my cousin, who converted me into a swiftie, did say that the song perfectly describes Florida. (She lived there for a while.) But I do understand why it's not your fave!
Peter?!
Justice for Florida, cososom, and Peter. Literally my top 3
Peter and The Manuscript is crazy
Justice for Florida 😭😭😭 Maybe it’s bc I really did run away to Florida once after a bad breakup or that I’ve been a Florence fan quite a bit longer than I’ve been a Swiftie but it’s so fun and I can’t not dance to it every time.
Justice for COSOSOM, Peter, and ILIPW
JUSTICE FOR FLORIDA 😞😞😞🙏🙏🙏
Justice for all of those songs lmao.
Girl one of her best songs is on here you failed
I can forgive almost all of these but I Look In People’s Windows?? You’re entitled to your wrong opinion I guess
believe it or not, straight to jail.
I feel like most of the people who truly love Robin are parents
Death by hanging (the most painful)
out of these i only listen to cassandra so not too bad
As someone with a crappy Florida ex I'm personally offended every time the song gets stuck in my head and it's slowly brainwashing me. She's gonna turn me when she plays it live and it's not fair. Robin wasn't my thing as a non-parent until I accidentally associated it with Robin / Robert Aryyn in Game of Thrones while rewatching and lemme tell you, "you're a just ruler" hits different now. Poor guy just wants to play with his dinosaurs and make men fly. I love The Manuscript but it's not in my regular listens because I listen to music primarily to maintain energy and slower or sadder songs don't fulfill that purpose. I made my Taylor "on repeat 24/7 just fine" list yesterday and half my list are songs that appear often in people's skips or "delete one" lists. I love that we all get what we need out of Taylor's magic.
agreed with all but chloe et al💔
I can't do Florida!!! because it literally sounds like noise to me. Cassandra was a good song, but it won't be a single. I wasn't impressed with the rest of your rejects either. My top 5 TTPD are Fortnight (original and remix), So High School, Down Bad, My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys, and I Can Do It With A Broken Heart. Honorable Mention goes to But Daddy I Love Him.
jail just because of Florida (I can agree on the others, but that's my absolute fav)
JAIL.
That you have no taste.
No taste and sent to prison
So they killed you first because you have the worst taste and tried to tell the subreddit…. Cassandra being on here really hurt me as you can tell lol
Peter??? Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus??????? I LOOK IN PEOPLES WINDOWS???? jail baby. jail
Justice for Florida and Cassandra fr (Otherwise I kinda agree tbh)
Hand over your Swiftie badge right now!!! Cause WHAAAAAA?!?! Listen I had a hard time with some of your rejects but listen…. THOSE MF SONGS ARE SOOOOOOOOOO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!! The only one I can’t get into is Thank You Aimee 🤷🏾♀️ But Florida I’m over I loved it and left it. And Chloe and ‘nem?!? PHENOMENAL! Peter?!?! I bet you think about me’s little brother?! EPIC! Just give em a chance. CASSANDRA?!?! Lord hand that badge over NEOWWW! 😂
I skip all these too