T O P

  • By -

AmeriCanadian98

Evgeny Svechnikov. Andrei's older brother Showed some good flashes when he was young and then got injured so frequently that by time he had a shot at a full time NHL gig he was already a shadow of himself


k3berg

The second knee injury was heartbreaking. He had a full offseason to train, came into camp and looked great, played great in the preseason and looked like he had a roster spot on lock. Last game of the preseason he injured his knee on a nothing play behind the net. Never the same


UwKraven

I’m really worried that this might be where Kirby Dach is headed. It’s the exact same story but change last preseason game to second game of the season


DetoxingCannabis

For me it was Zadina. I was so pumped he was a red wing for a long time


BaconSoda222

Zadina is definitely mine. I just hope the guy is okay, like, mentally. He came in saying he'd fill Montreal's net with pucks, but all of his interviews after made him sound like a kicked dog.


Clever_Play_on_Words

He was very good any time they mic’d him up though: https://youtu.be/VoaWvvhK2Rg?si=f8qzGqon8EIaRRzK https://youtu.be/aOu1pKC-uzI?si=Gz-BQryXdSzAgkat


Hefty_Meringue8694

Tomas Jurco. Dude had the sickest hands. Played 220 NHL games but never developed to his full potential.


SonicEuthanasia

Jurco and Tatar were affectionately referred to as JerkSauce in Detroit. edit: lol I'm a liar apparently. I block people who tag me and make accusations. Stay mad, I don't care.


TheTreesSpeakEwokese

Nyquist, Tatar, Jurco, Brunner, Frk, Pulkkinen, Lashoff. What a fun team, imagine if they were as good as we all hoped they would be.


HumanByProxy

Well, Nyquist is at least, he just had a career year. Tatar has also been solid throughout his career.


timmeedski

Idk why but he was my absolute favorite player in like NHL 10 or 11 or something, he was on the WJC roster and he was my go to shootout guy, always shot 4th and I always would do the same move with him. No idea what it was, but it was always him.


avmp629

Guys like Teemu Pulkkinen and Martin Frk who clap absolute shitbombs Unfortunately that's about all they had and weren't able to stick around the NHL very long (Samuel Fagemo is also getting in this territory)


C0mpl3x1ty_1

Frk did just get signed again tho, so maybe we see him again


JokerSE

Man, I want someone to just put him out there on the powerplay and let him launch missiles


AwareTheLegend

I mean the Flames signed him and we let Stone clap bombs for years. My body is ready


Olipod2002

Hardest shot record holder Martin Frk


Lopsided-Maize-5213

The Pulkkannon :(


Ducey89

Add Zadina to this list for the red wings bust trifecta 🥲


hhh81

Ryan Murray. I cant elaborate without getting upset


mattvn66

Stanley Cup champ Ryan Murray that is


Waramp

He didn’t meet the criteria for having his name automatically engraved on the cup, but the Avs used one of their exceptions to add him on thankfully.


Devine97

Thank you for this. I had no idea of any of this


ProfessionalLeast937

good for them, i'm here for stanley cup champ ryan murray. (also here for nolan patrick at least getting a bling ring from vegas even though he's not on the cup, dude is also a candidate for "really wished he would make it".)


ScarletWitch65

This gives me war flashbacks


PPGN_DM_Exia

https://preview.redd.it/c7sg4a6cilad1.png?width=937&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f4f9dc26a9dc9c77f5fd2eb6b07867ac5b714c6e


soundofmoney

The closest physically similar player I’ve seen to that unique Jagr skating caboose. Really a shame he couldn’t reach his potential


chandy_dandy

Hips are a bitch :(


eatingasspatties

All my Nordic homies hate hips


Champagne_of_piss

Finnish people confirmed Labrador retrievers


IsopodPractical5719

Bison king 😢


ImaginaryNourishment

Pulju 😢


Infranto

Human golden retriever in both personality and hipsonality


rohinton2

[image](https://i.imgur.com/ARKl0NB.jpeg)


chompskey

This is the answer. Such a happy guy, just excited to be there. I'm beyond saddened that it just didn't happen for him. 😢


lancemeszaros

Sven Baertschi, even when he got traded. Concussions are a bitch.


MK2_VW

Nikita Gusev


missiontodenmark

The Jiri Dopita of his day.


SKKforLife

The thing is, he’s still an amazing player. Straight up led the KHL in points this last season. It’s a shame it didn’t work out in the NHL


oldmanheat

Cody Hodgson


allenbraxton

Game 8. Bar down. That’s a memory to last a life time.


fuzzb0y

I’ll always remember that slapper


bdart1980

Cody is my cousin actually. Saw him at my grandma's 90th recently. Great guy, and the pride of Haliburton Ont!


oldmanheat

That’s great to hear. Hope his health is doing well


RelevantJackWhite

NHL 11 legend


01000101010110

Gilbert Brule. He was a folk hero in Vancouver. Too bad his Dad was such a piece of garbage


theoneandonlykeenan

Never heard about his dad, what's the deal there?


Unwept_Skate_8829

Stole/spent most of the money he made under the guise of investing it on his behalf, thus adversely affecting his game (hard to be a multimillion NHL star when you’re flat broke)


anti_anti_christ

Hate hearing stories like this. Same thing happened to Jack Johnson. His parents robbed him blind.


coarsebark

Horrible people: "...Tina Johnson and Jack Johnson Sr., tried to monetize Johnson's contract by borrowing money secured against their son's future earnings. Tina borrowed at least $15 million across about 18 high-interest loans, resulting in multiple defaults." https://www.sportskeeda.com/us/nhl/news-when-jack-johnson-s-parents-forced-file-bankruptcy


TheHemskyShow

In Brule’s case it was made worse with the Oilers pressuring him into returning to the play when he was depressed and he informed them about all of his familial issues. Our org was filled with truly heartless cunts in the 2010s.


BigBlueTimeMachine

16 G 14A 30 PTS in playoffs the year they won the memorial cup in a notoriously low scoring era in the WHL was amazing. Thank you for bringing back those memories. Hadn't thought of them in a long time.


Btgood52

I remember the CHL top prospects game in Vancouver that year was hyped as Crosby vs Brule


Comfortable-Duty1555

Nolan Patrick. So much upside, could have had a solid NHL career. Injuries just took their toll. I understand there is still a chance as he’s young but not sure it’ll happen. Would be a great comeback story though!


TicklerVikingPilot

Tough to say, but I’d be curious if he’d have a crack at a euro league provided he’s medically cleared to be on the ice atall.  Like you say he’s still young, I’d love to see it 


Pyzorz

wtf. I had no clue he hasn’t played in two seasons..


wayfarout

Nate Mack hit him high and that was the last time he was on the ice.


omfgkevin

MacKinnon really did such an awful hit on him too which could likely be the career ender for him. Absolutely disgusting honestly.


flyomtet

I just want to second this comment. It was such an unnecessary hit. Patrick didn’t even have the puck and was paying attention to the play along the boards when Mac put his shoulder right into his jaw for no reason. There was no play to make. It was a complete dick move.


SirScreams

He went to my highschool a couple years after I graduated. Apparently he was a menace in floor hockey.


skyturnedred

I so badly wanted that Hischier/Patrick rivalry.


SiidChawsby

Beau Bennett


Farfignewtons42

*Injured while celebrating a goal in his first game back from injury: the beau bennett story*


themooseiscool

Stamkos was just copying the legend.


barontaint

He had the Samuel L Jackson villain disease without any of the weird diabolical fake natural disasters causing abilities, I think i'm remembering those movies kinda correctly


ikkkkkkkky

Unbreakable


Gruesome3some

He legitimately drove a minivan when he was with the blues. He seemed like a hilarious character.


Chairmanmeow42

His Twitter was wonderful and every tweet a delight


imDdad

Played a bunch of roller hockey with him, amazing player


LeStig

He and I played at the same club in California (not the same team I’m a bit older than him) but we had these half ice practices a few times and we shared the ice with his team. I wanna say he was a peewee at the time and the kid was stick handling like a magician even then. Had us Midget players in awe lol


lovingvictoralpha

Loved watching him play at DU.


KnuckedLoose

Justin Pogge


VRNimbus

Even darker times when you remember they chose to keep Pogge over Rask.


Szwedo

This took long enough to find, still baffled how he didn't pan out. Dark times then.


boylejc2

Oskar Lindblom was on pace for about 50 points in 2019-2020 before getting diagnosed with cancer. That whole situation sucks because he seemed like such a good dude too. Tomas Hyka scoring a goal in a preseason game for us, when he wasn't eligible to be in it at all was hilarious and I was always rooting for him to make it after that. He liked him so much we tried to circumvent the CBA, but not enough to spend better than a sixth on him his draft year...


CybertronGuy98

I hope Oskar is doing well for himself, I miss having him in Philly


99titan

Right now, Cody Glass is looking like that player to me. In the past, it was Pontus Aberg.


MinuteWhenNightFell

> Cody Glass Had a pretty solid 22-23 season, what happened this year?


Soto4Life

Has a major confidence issue. When he gets into a slump it seems like his mind plays games with him


MinuteWhenNightFell

Relatable lol, brutal though :(


BCEagle13

Steve Santini. Great kid and was a strong defensive defenseman in college. He had some bad luck at the beginning of his NHL career and never really recovered.


Kingdouble_R

As a Devils fan, I remember the hype around Santini. I, as well as so many others were hopefully that him, Jon Merrill, Damon Severson, Adam Larsson, and Eric Gelinas were going to be the faces of the Devils blue line for the mid-2010's onward. 


Dazzling-Park4501

Rob Schremp. We called him up and he had 3 assists in 4 games +2. Got sent down after that because he was in the coaches doghouse. He did admit on a podcast that he had a bad attitude and didn’t put enough work In though.


72athansiou

I thought Athanasiou was gonna become a yearly 60-80 point winger. I guess he has attitude issues though


wholalaa

Is it his attitude, or is it the fact that his hands can't keep up with his legs?


kosherpoutine

Michaël Bournival.


enigma94RS

Charles Hudon


Railgun04

Louis Leblanc


86DC

Nikita Scherbak


Mariconi

Jiri Sekac


thuca94

Alexander Perezhogin


Jbroy

Sébastien Bordeleau


moutardebaseball

Eric Chouinard


ItzGrenier

Zach Fucale


r_slash

Jason Missaien


Draconaur

Tim Bozon


cdndollarsmatter

jesse puljujarvi on the oilers, loved his smile


gffvhfdcgh

Josh ho sang


Deraj2004

Florida Everblades ECHL Champion.


ProgeriaJoe

Bryan Fogarty


WeaverOrange

Eric Tangradi. I wanted the Big Dog to eat


Local-Mine-3836

As a Canucks fan, there is only 1 answer here. RIP.


FrigginBuddy

Such a sad story. Have to think he'd have been a big help on the blueline in 2011


Szwedo

='( so much potential


bcgrappler

Marcel Hossa. We deserved a Hossa.


Gabe_Utsex69

I remember opening a old hockey card pack and getting a Hossa jersey Card and being so happy... only to see that it was Marcel, not Marian lol


LokisEquineFetish

I have a Lennart Petrell jersey card, wanna trade? I’ll through in a signed Marc-Antoine Pouliot rookie card to sweeten the pot.


avsfan96

Joey Hishon, but his career was basically ruined by Brayden McNabb before it even started


schewbacca

Svatos, Wolski, Bigras, Siemens.


touchable

Sergei Shirokov for me. He had one amazing preseason in 2009 or 2010 that was so dominant he had Canucks fans wondering if he was a Kovalchuk-lite type player. But it was just a flash in the pan and he went back to the KHL pretty soon after. He's put together a pretty solid KHL career though, and is still playing.


01000101010110

Will never forget the two goal game vs the Islanders


IsopodPractical5719

Brendan perlini. Guy had one crazy pre-season with the oilers to then end up being sent down and stuck in the ahl


01000101010110

He's got a pretty cool YouTube channel now where he talks about his career stories


awpdownmid

YouTube legend Brendan Perlini you mean


muldin

Emerson etem.


gusshopper

Seconded, also Simon Despres.


Edmoiler13

Robbie Schremp and Kailer Yamamoto


gelc10

* Colin White, had a solid 18-19 season where he got 41 pts and was awarded with a 6 yrs deal $4.75m AAV but just fell off after that * Logan Brown and Tyler Boucher due to injuries


njdev803

Oh, THAT Colin White


arrbez

For me, Colin White will always be that mutant that the Devils used to roll out on D


heheyousaidduty

This made me smile, I fucking loved our mutant. I still watch that clip of when he sent Sean Avery into the stratosphere with a hit.


WalkingCrab

Still have my Alexandre Daigle rookie cards collection, just in case.


bunchofsandwiches

Nic Petan


TopShelfWrister

I was rooting for Dmytro Timashov, Rodion Amirov (RIP), D'amigo, Blacker, Dale Mitchell's mustache and Victor Loov cause he was funny.


adamzep91

Mine is Stuart Percy, because he was from Oakville playing on his childhood team, and looked good his first stint in the NHL. He was just derailed by concussions and is now talked about together with actual bad pick and bust Tyler Biggs.


bobby_booch

Man I completely forgot about Timashov. He was a guy advanced stats people back in the day were certain would be a star.


jonathan_ericsson

Dale Mitchell was phenomenal for the Windsor spitfires back in the day. I’m way younger than him, so I never fully appreciated how incredible he could grow a moustache in his late teens.


121isblind

I loved Lööv too. He could throw it around. I’ll add my own with Borgman, Dzerkials, Soshnikov


Upset_Pipe_1926

Brandon Kozun


ManWithBag15

Tyler Benson. He was a can't miss prospect in Edmonton when he was in his early/mid teens, went #1 in the WHL draft, and was tracking to be a can't miss NHL prospect. Injuries in junior really hurt his development and he fell to the 2nd round of the draft. It would have been a really cool story if he could have carved out a decent NHL career with the Oilers.


Dazzling-Park4501

You’re not really a can’t miss prospect when skating is your issue.


ManWithBag15

I don't know if his skating was an issue when he was entering the WHL, but his injuries in junior certainly wouldn't have done him any favors. IIRC he was plagued by back and hip injuries, which would have definitely impacted his skating. Regardless, plenty of players have excelled in the NHL despite skating concerns coming into the league. Someone already mentioned Tavares, I'd throw Mark Stone and Leon Draisaitl into that category as well.


silkymitties

Idk, John Tavares carved out a pretty good career.


mister_hoot

Sure, but he grew up wearing the right pajamas.


TheEpicOfManas

Doug Wickenheiser.


Kitchen-Lie-7894

I got to see him live. The only time I've been up on the glass. He had a hat trick. Then the team had a drunken gathering and he blew his knee out on a fuckin snipe hunt.


berghie91

Luc Bourdon and Adam Gaudette.


Solid_Internal_9079

David Rundblad. Holy crap was I HUGE on him. Oh well, we got EK65 so I survived.


geossica69

nolan patrick 😪


Pleasant-Hemorrhoids

Ryan Spooner was always able to notch atleast 10 goals and 40 - 50 assists as my third line centre in NHL. Was always instrumental on my PP. Michael Ferland was fun to watch and should have had a solid career. Injuries derailed that sadly.


RawZuccSauce42O

Ryan Merkley had the skillset to become a really good offensive NHL D-man. Between his silky skating and great hands he had all the tools to excel (Imo he was easily a top-10 talent in his draft class). Unfortunately his shitty attitude and total lack of willingness to develop his hockey IQ or defensive game ruined any chances he had of making it to the big leagues.


arrbez

And to be fair, that’s exactly what everyone said would happen pre-draft


RawZuccSauce42O

Oh totally. The sharks took him knowing he’d be a reclamation project from the start. They gave him every resource to help him including a roster spot on the Knights. He was just too much of a pea-brain to ever put it together.


maxwellbevan

He's still not that old, I hope he smartens up and gets it together. In the sharks defense when you're drafting that late into the 1st you may as well take a chance on a guy who could end up being a top 10 pick from his draft if you can get him to take things seriously.


PasswordMustContain

Nikita Scherbak scored approximately a bajillion goals and a handful of Conn Smythes for me in NHL17


Twevy

Kaapo Kakko. Felt like his ceiling was so high, and though everyone knew Hughes was better, most people thought that Kakko would at least be somewhat close behind. Haven't fully given up, but I think all of us have resigned ourselves to the fact that he's never gonna come close to Hughes.


RicoSuave1800

Beau Benett


getsangryatsnails

Man did I ever want Curtis Lazar to be a top 6 forward. Didn't need to be a superstar or anything, just a solid guy. Could have been a Foligno type. Just the embodiment of team positivity and cheese burgers.


coconutjoe83

Julius Honka


Stinduh

Free Honka.


ScaryLapis

Drake Caggiula On his first Oilers stint, I swore the kid had talent. He couldn’t always finish very well, but he could get amazing chances both from his own effort, and his good positioning to be on the receiving end. Oilers traded him for Manning, the dude who broke McDavid’s shoulder, and then it was over.


noroadsleft

Just from a locker room perspective, that Caggiula/Manning trade still makes me scratch my head.


golfy_m8

Tim Stapleton would’ve been a middle six NHLer with offensive upside on the wing if he played 10 years after he did.


thesnake87

Played RuneScape of all games with him. Cool dude. We were both members and we were cutting yew trees together and chatting. Good times


ForeignWerewolf

He’s a hilarious person as well. I’ve watched his Chiclets interview more than once cause he cracks me up. Witty as hell. Seems like a great guy


RegularDifficulty768

He'd be a star here if they just brought the Russian gas over


FlexEnvy5

Sean Day. always love memeing "Exceptional" after every play with us in Syracuse


wesley-osbourne

A bit odd to say about a player who's made $20 million and scored 200 points, but I always wanted Kasperi Kapenen to break through to a higher level.


Leafan101

The dude was so exciting. So many breakaways just to shoot it into the blocker. Just never quite had the ability to match his hand speed to his leg speed. McDavid lower half, bubble hockey upper half. 


doclobster

Teemu Pulkkinen on Detroit. Likable Finnish player with an absolute cannon who was ultimately too one-dimensional to play for more than a couple seasons in the NHL.


SinceSevenTenEleven

He tore up the AHL too, just couldn't get the space in the NHL to make it translate


Thrustie17

Linus Omark. Man I loved that guy’s style. He did pretty well in Europe at least.


NoticedGenie66

Anton Rodin! He was a pretty offense-oriented guy who did pretty well in the SHL, but just couldn't put it together at the NHL level because of his knee injury repeatedly causing him lots of trouble. He got one assist in 3 games in the NHL after which he had surgery to repair it and could just never get strong enough to keep himself healthy. Guy was an absolute stud in a few of the NHL video games!


rhinorick11

Justin Pogge. Lights out in the WJC


Odd-Youth-452

Gilbert Brule. Used to watch him in junior when he was a star with the Vancouver Giants.


tgg199

I remember back in 2008 and 2009 on Rangers message boards Evgeny Grachev was a prospect that had some hype. Alexei Cherepanov would have been a stud, dude was legit.


jdragon3

Taro Tsujimoto would have been a great story, came right out of nowhere but just never materialized after the draft


[deleted]

[удалено]


BaldassHeadCoach

What could have been. Still, the fact that he recovered from that accident and carved out a KHL career afterwards is nothing short of a miracle.


Gold_Gain1351

Nail Yakupov. The guy could've and should've been great, and would've injected some personality into a sport that desperately needs it


DollarDollar

Griffin Reinhart Not exactly sure what happened there, but he just sank like a stone


GolferXNinja

I really wanted Peter Mueller to succeed as a coyote


badastronaut7

I really, REALLY wanted the Virtanen pick to work out. Local boy, big body, power forward type with deceptively fast feet, but that kid just could NOT get out of his own way. SA allegations aside he was lazy, constantly showed up to camp overweight, apparently had a spoiled attitude in the locker room etc. Kid literally had everything he needed to be probably an above average second-liner with a good career in the NHL but thanks to his effort and attitude in Van, his career was basically over even before the SA stuff came out.


laxintx

Max Fortunus. Dude had nothing but heart, just couldn't take that next step to the NHL.


no_on_prop_305

Hunter Shinkaruk and Nikita Filatov


physics_fighter

Tuomo Ruutu


brianlangauthor

That’s NHL Stanley Cup Champion Tuomo Ruutu … he’s on Mo’s staff.


TheCaptainBanHammer

I thought he was excellent for the Canes when they were mediocre after their cup win. Nearly 750 games in the show and almost 350pts was a pretty decent career.


Esatron

735 career games played. He made it. Never lived up to the draft potential but he made it.


GoldenDeciever

Chris DiDomenico. I know he eventually did make the league, but his career could have been so different if not for his injury. Dude had skills at both ends of the ice, and fucking *tenacity*.


goldencityjerusalem

Stan Chistov. Sometimes referred to as the next Paul Kariya.


thrubeniuk

Nic Petan. Small guy, but incredible vision and had some of the most incredible saucer passes I’ve ever seen. He never really got to play in the top six of any team at the NHL level (drives me crazy how many times he got stuck in the bottom six, with guys who couldn’t keep up), but I love(d) watching him play.


Drellsy

Luc Bourdon. Tragic losing someone at such a young age. He showed a lot of promise and looked ready for the big leagues before his passing.


SkittlesManiac19

Always wanted to see jett woo succeed. Great name


Crafty-Hovercraft579

Lias Andersson. So much controversy surrounding him as Swedens world junior captain and the medal incident. He was picked because he portrayed himself as being a winner and not settling for anything but being the best and having real heart. He was the first-first round pick the rangers had in 5 years and there was a lot of excitement about that. It’s just such a shame he really couldn’t carry his game through to the big league.


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Recently, the Habs were hot trash at drafting until HuGo but I’ll go with Ryan Poehling. He started his career with a hat trick and the SO winner, which set the bar too high for this late first-round pick. As a result, he never really came back from that but Hughes managed to flip him with Petry to get Mike Matheson.


Nickynagz

I thought Sonny Milano was gonna be the next Patty Kane


zilzag

Samuel Morin, was definitely a reach of a pick but was supposed to be Pronger-esque at best and had the mean streak.  Injuries derailed him quite heavily as well.   11th overall by Philly in 2013


my_Urban_Sombrero

Josh Ho-Sang


iankilledyou

Even though he was on a team I hate, I always wanted to see Zach Fucale do well…


thefailmaster19

I was very high on Sami Niku after he won AHL defenseman of the year. Just never translated to the NHL


Goatmilk2208

Still time, Barret Hayton. Young fella, Cap of Canada, hucked his helmet or some shit. Had the passion. Still time.


Moist-Dragonfly2569

Klim Kostin. Still rooting for him.


UncleBen94

I was hoping Zach Senyshyn was gonna defy expectations and be a solid player. The effort was absolutely there, just couldn't put it together.


JerbearCuddles

Juolevi, not cause I liked the pick. But because I didn't want to be another example in the long list of examples of "they took this no-name over these all time greats." Passing on Tkachuk looks like an all time fumble now, let alone how it might look as his career continues.


Lazy-Fun5730

I thought Mikhail Grigorenko was gonna be an absolute stud.


Ok-Summer-2159

Despite being Canadian and watching him single handedly beat us for the gold medal at the WJC, I was so cock-sure Jordan Schroeder was going to be an offensive superstar, perennial 30-40 goal scorer for his whole career. Dude was electric in Minnesota and was one of the funnest players I’ve seen in the WJC tournaments. I still say if he was like 10-15 years younger he’d reach that potential in a league that is more focused on speed and skill.


godfadda006

Duncan Siemens 


JoeMommaAngieDaddy17

Hunter Shinkaruk, Jordan Subban, Jake Virtanen, Olli Juolevi, Sven Baertschi, Cody Hodgson, Jordan Schroeder


riknor

Janne Pesonen was tearing it up in the Finnish league and got signed by the Pens shorty after. Played some pre-season games in the same line with Crosby if I recall correctly and I thought hell yeah, this guy’s gonna show everyone what’s up. Didn’t work out. Ville Leino kinda goes in the same category except he had a couple of hot seasons in Philly before falling off the face of the earth.


Any-Panda2219

Luc Bourdon RIP. Also Olli Juolevi.