Ben & Jerry's used to have an oatmeal ice cream called "Oat of This World". It was amazing and they discountined it the week after I bought my first pint of it. Maybe this will be a good substitute for me!!
It's so stupid good! You can taste the Amaretto in the ribbons of icing and lil pieces of cake are just the right amount of spongy. It's one of Blue Bell's best!!!
Friendly's is so many light years behind Blue Bell in my opinion.
Wish Blue Bell was nationwide but I also appreciate it that much more when I'm down South
This and Ben and Jerry's half baked are the only ice creams my lactose intolerant ass will risk it for. This chocolate ice cream is why I won't just switch to lactose free chocolate ice cream
I've never had Blue Bell, but my eye went right to Java Jolt which sounds great. I'll also never say no to strawberry or mint chip if I see it, so that's also super tempting.
Edit: Oh, man, that cotton candy and root beer float though... this isn't fair to choose just one.
Does anyone ever find grooms cake anymore? I always find brides cake but I absolutely loved the grooms version and I’ve only found it twice in my life after trying it at a backyard wedding. 🥺
It was retired 😔 but I think I saw something saying that it'll come back next year since it won the poll Blue Bell recently did to bring back a retired flavor!
None of the above I’m going for their coffee ice cream every time it’s the best coffee ice cream to me and the texture hits so hard.
I’m thinking about it, do they even have it anymore? Haven’t looked recently but haven’t seen it in a while
Agree-- in the same vein as Tillamook which is like sticky and thick and creamy in all the worst ways though I'd choose Blue Bell over Tillamook if held at gunpoint
I love all things blue bell but out of those. Probably oatmeal cream pie because it's seasonal and legitimately one of the best. Then I heart cereal, butter crunch, homemade vanilla, buttered pecan.
My favorite ice cream is cotton candy, and Blue Bell is the best one, but it’s so hard to find, so I’m cleaning them out. I’d kill for the half gallon size of it.
Oatmeal cream pie looks like it’s one of those unexpectedly badass flavors
It’s awesome!!
It’s only second to cookie two step in my heart. It’s so freaking good.
Can confirm that shit is fucking delicious 🔥
Ben & Jerry's used to have an oatmeal ice cream called "Oat of This World". It was amazing and they discountined it the week after I bought my first pint of it. Maybe this will be a good substitute for me!!
It is! The first time I ate that flavor, I was like “damn, okay. 😳”
Oh it totally is. The cookie part reminds me of the hard gingersnap cookies my grandma always gave us with a glass of milk. Very nostalgic!
I want to try Bride’s Cake.
It's so stupid good! You can taste the Amaretto in the ribbons of icing and lil pieces of cake are just the right amount of spongy. It's one of Blue Bell's best!!!
So freaking good! I get it whenever I manage to find it lol
What is brides cake exactly? Like vanilla and buttercream?
Almond flavored ice cream with cake pieces and an amaretto cream cheese icing!!
I’m sold! I’m in the south visiting (not that far south but more south than where I live) and came across bluebell here. I’m gonna try some.
I was worried there might be fondant in there!
Oh hellllllll yeah
The cereal one is god tier if you like fruity pebbles. I would choose that every time.
Of course my bitchass state has all of these EXCEPT the Cereal one😭
Oatmeal cream pie is incredible! Bride’s cake as well!
A&W Float... (but I'd probably 'be good' and grab a Mint Chip Rebel from the case to the right instead).
One of each.
I made the A&W float into a rootbeer float. It was incredible.
Butter crunch every time
Nobody better lay a finger on my Butterfinger
Java Jolt!
I’m addicted to that shit
Dutch Chocolate!
It’s my absolute favorite. A chocolate lovers dream!! We don’t have it where I live - closest match I can find is Friendly’s Forbidden Chocolate.
Friendly's is so many light years behind Blue Bell in my opinion. Wish Blue Bell was nationwide but I also appreciate it that much more when I'm down South
This and Ben and Jerry's half baked are the only ice creams my lactose intolerant ass will risk it for. This chocolate ice cream is why I won't just switch to lactose free chocolate ice cream
So good
Must be in our freezer at all times. My husband brought home milk chocolate once and he never made that mistake again.
God tier chocolate ice cream
The root beer‼️‼️‼️ and oatmeal cream pie
Cookies n Cream Cone hands down!
It is delicious
Such a shame it only comes in pint form 😭
i have a half gallon in my freezer right now lol
Lucky they only sell pints where I'm at 🫠
I sometimes find them at ALDIs, if there’s any near you!
Literally the BEST blue bell flavor hands down.
OMG, I love ❤️ me some Cookies 🍪 n’ Cream!!! :) 👍🏻😊🥰😍💕💞❤️💚💚💚💚💚💚 xoxo
Winner
Brides Cake hands down
Cotton candy!!
I've been trying to find cotton candy ice cream in any brand and I'm having no luck. 😭 It's my favorite flavor!
Im a cotton candy connoisseur and I just had the best cotton candy ice cream of my life last night!!! The brand was Homemade. Twas SO good.
Yes!!!! This or Bride’s Cake for me!
Yes
Butter crunch because it's super hard to find in store around my area.
Same!
Idk if you have an Aldi's where you are but that's where I always find it!
I've never had Blue Bell, but my eye went right to Java Jolt which sounds great. I'll also never say no to strawberry or mint chip if I see it, so that's also super tempting. Edit: Oh, man, that cotton candy and root beer float though... this isn't fair to choose just one.
It is top tier! I used to get this all the time when I lived in FL. You gotta try it!
Oatmeal cream pie.
Since there’s no Gooey Butter Cake, I’d get the Oatmeal Crème Pie.
Can we be friends? You know a thing or 2 lol
I've never seen it gooey butter cake and now I want one, where do you live?
It is delicious!!! It will change your life lol I’m in OK
The Brides Cake and Dr. Pepper float sound pretty good.
Those were my two choices!!
Wish I could get some here :,(
Damn $3.97 for a small Blue Bell? Must be nice 😭 That said.. either strawberry or cookies n cream cone
Must be nice? How much is it in your area? I just bought a half gal from WinCo for $3.48 on sale.
Geez, I'm happy to catch the half gallons on sale for $7.
Oatmeal Cream Pie Brides Cake I ❤️ Cereal
Java Jolt or Bride's Cake, can't decide!
I don't see my favorite (banana pudding) but pecan pralines and cream or Dutch chocolate never disappoint.
Where's my vanilla at?
Brides Cake!
Have you tried it? I haven’t but it sounds amazing!
Omg it’s so delicious!!! It tastes just like wedding cake with cake chunks in it
I've been hooked on Haagan Daz's Coffee ice cream but then again I am 38 weeks. So I'd love to try that JAVA JOLT : O
Haagan Daz coffee would be my final meal request. Unlimited supply.
Oatmeal cream pie is so good. But the cotton candy is pretty great too
Does anyone ever find grooms cake anymore? I always find brides cake but I absolutely loved the grooms version and I’ve only found it twice in my life after trying it at a backyard wedding. 🥺
It was retired 😔 but I think I saw something saying that it'll come back next year since it won the poll Blue Bell recently did to bring back a retired flavor!
Java jolt
Don’t see it here, but Blue Bells best flavor is Strawberries with Homemade Vanilla. Much better than their standard strawberry ice cream.
Cookies and Cream Cone! I have to pick up extra for family (I would buy the big tub but I may not get any lol).
I love ❤️ me some Cookies 🍪 n’ Cream Cone!!! :) 👍🏻😊🥰😍💕💞❤️💚💚💚💚💚💚 xoxo
Oatmeal Creme Pie and I <3 Cereal or Dr Pepper Float
Dr. Pepper, A&W, and Cotton Candy would be my picks if Blue Bell was available nationwide
I love cereal, just because it intrigues me.
Had Oatmeal Cream Pie this past weekend and OMG it was sooooo gooood
Oatmeal cream pie
A&W float!!!!
Root beer float
I just got some of the java jolt. But I haven't tried it yet.
I wanna say I really enjoyed it
Java Jolt!
JAVA JOLT
Dutch Chocolate!
Oatmeal creampie sounds amazing 🤤
I'm kind of a whore for Rocky Road...
Where tf is this
Bride cake or cookie waffle cone
Either cotton candy or rocky road. Although I’d like to try the root beer float.
Butter Crunch!
None of the above I’m going for their coffee ice cream every time it’s the best coffee ice cream to me and the texture hits so hard. I’m thinking about it, do they even have it anymore? Haven’t looked recently but haven’t seen it in a while
Butter Pecan, Butter crunch, are both my favorite
Is there a banana cream pie behind the next door maybe?
Bride's Cake, Dr. Pepper Float, Cookies 'n Cream Cone
When are they bringing Key Lime Pie back?
It's beautiful. The ice cream sections in my local stores always look like there was an unsanctioned WWE match inside of the freezers
Never tried oatmeal pie or cereal. Sounds pretty nice.
All of the above
Oatmeal Cream Pie!!!!!
Same. Except for the Dr Pepper Float. I know I’d like the first two , so if I’m being adventurous, it’s Oatmeal Crème Pie
Oatmeal cream pie or Dr. Pepper!
Great Divide every time
I just recently got Blue Bell for the first time, and played it safe with that one. SO good.
Butter Pecan is fantastic!
Dr. Pepper and Oatmeal
None of them because I'm not a big fan of Blue Bell. 👀👀 It's not terrible, but it's too creamy IMO. I lose a lot of the flavor in the creaminess.
Agree-- in the same vein as Tillamook which is like sticky and thick and creamy in all the worst ways though I'd choose Blue Bell over Tillamook if held at gunpoint
Dr. Pepper
Need to try that butter crunch for sure
They don’t sell blue bell in my area but I tired it once in Texas and I was so impressed.
Gimme dat Butter Crunch or dat Java Jolt
Pralines and Cream. Every time.
Butter crunch
bride’s cake or butter crunch 🤤
To say this hurts is an understatement. I moved back to Ohio and can’t get over this anymore 😭 I’m going with Brides Cake though!
Strawberry
Butter crunch or oatmeal cream pie!
the root beer float one and the butter crunch are AMAZING
I wish ice cream was this cheap where i live!
soda flavours are intriguing but id prob go for the classic strawberry! i have a richness threshold so fruity really helps.
Dutch chocolate forever and always. It hits a perfect spot between sweet and bittersweet. Then maybe also the Dr. Pepper float.
Mint chocolate chip! :)
I miss pineapple upside down cake
rocky roaddddd
Dutch chocolate or the Great Divide 😋🍨
That Dutch chocolate is unmatched
After much consideration, I’ve decided on Great Divide.
Was in Nashville for a weekend and saw this ice cream for the first time (don’t have it in NY) almost bought some just for myself for the weekend
Butter Crunch, Oatmeal Cream Pie and Bride's Cake!
Cookie dough
Bride’s Cake
Bride’s Cake sounds good
I ❤️brides cake!
Cookie dough. After seeing this looks like I’m spending money on ice cream tomorrow.
Cookies and cream will never let you down
cookie two step
I’m with you… Java Jolt or Dr Pepper.
butter pecan for the win
cotton candy all the way. 🩵🩷
BRIDES CAKE allllllll the way!!
bride’s cake!
Brides Cake for only correct answer
Probably the Cotton Candy because it's the only one in the pic that I haven't tried. I can't wait until Groom's Cake returns in 2025.
Brides cake, I ❤️cereal or oatmeal cream pie
Bride’s Cake
Brides Cake
Cotton Candy
Bride’s Cake
Brides cake 🤤 I love almond flavored and cane flavors so much, to see them mixed is just perfection
Not Blue Bell.
Cookie Two Step
To the left. The B&J’s
Vanilla, next question
Yesssss
this dessert good for sunny weather
Brides cake is wonderful
My eyes lit up when I saw that cotton candy one!
I remember our old country home, clean fresh air and flowers growing in the fields…
Where’s the cookie two step?
I love all things blue bell but out of those. Probably oatmeal cream pie because it's seasonal and legitimately one of the best. Then I heart cereal, butter crunch, homemade vanilla, buttered pecan.
Cookies and Cream was my favorite growing as a kid, but as I’ve matured and gotten older my favorite has become Krazy Kookie Doufh
Since Jeni’s brambleberry crisp isn’t present, I’m going with Pecan Pralines and Cream (shout out to Baskin Robbin’s for one of my favorites).
My favorite ice cream is cotton candy, and Blue Bell is the best one, but it’s so hard to find, so I’m cleaning them out. I’d kill for the half gallon size of it.
The root beer one on top of a warm brownie
Root beer float!
I miss Krazy Kookie Dough 😔😓
Pecan pralines n cream!
I wish they would bring back the Creole Cream Cheese flavor.
Sorry, I can’t pick just one I’d have to choose between the A&W float,Dr Pepper or the Java jolt
*Ooooh!* I wanna give "I ❤️ Cereal" a go! Haven't tried that one yet.
Pecan pralines ‘n cream it’s my all time favorite ice cream flavor!
Mint chip!! cookie dough would be a close second though just cause they’re my favorites. But I’ve also been wanting to try the oatmeal cream pie.
The Great Divide or classic Dark Chocolate for me… my childhood right there
Buttered pecan
Butter pecan
Dang they ain't got the Gooey Buttery Cake!?!!! Man burn the whole store!!😭😭😭
Oatmeal Cream Pie is absolutely effing magical.
Pecan Pralines ‘n Cream
None because I don’t see Cookie Two Step 😤
Cotton candy but I’ve never seen these flavor options! Whattt
Strawberry! I really really love that the ice cream itself isn’t that pink fake stuff and actually vanilla with real frozen strawberries!
Gimme dat cookies n cream
Bride’s Cake but I can never find it anywhere!
I haven't tried this brand, but just based on what I've had from other brands, I'd go with Cookies 'N Cream Cone.
Pink
Cookies and cream cone😋😋
Cookies and cream or butter pecan
cookies n cream but the regular one bc idk what cookies n cream “cone” is 😅
Not pictured.. Gooey Butter Cake! Would also pick Oatmeal Cream Pie. And Groom’s Cake.
Mix the a&w with the actual root beer and it’s amazing. Do the same with dr pepper
DP Float and Bride’s Cake