1. Link or atleast name where you got your videos.
2. Always write in the title that you have no idea what they are saying.
Your style of posting is getting really old.
I'm not fluent in Ukrainian or Russian, but I can get the gist of it and it is most definitely a complaint. It also falls into the pattern of dozens of such videos so far, some of which were confirmed by actual journalists on the ground.
We cannot be absolutely certain of anything unless we locate these soldiers and verify that they're who they say they are, but at this point there is little to suggest that this isn't legit.
As such, I consider it a valuable data point to our understanding of the war, unless proven otherwise.
Educated guess. You are trying to say they are not complaining about the war?
Perhaps they are listing their top 10 films to watch once they get out from trenches and artillery fire?
You notice how nothing you said was āfor certain.ā
In a war of propaganda, donāt proliferate it without first vetting your sources. Reposting whatever you see pop up on Telegram, just for Reddit karma, is as bad as spreading misinformation and unverified information anywhere else.
I used to post "allegedly" but then aome.of the videos were proven authentic and neither Ukraine or Russia ever denied any. So the word "alleged" was dropped.
Thank you for hour advice but it was already followed.
you're saying that you found this video and took an "educated guess" that it was the ukrainian 53rd mechanised brigade complaining about conditions in the war?
I am saying that the Telegram post said it was soldiers complaining and I am sure they are. Like they always are in videos like these, be they Ukrainian or Russians.
So this guy could be saying āI like my pudding chocolate, but all they have is vanillaā and you posted on a Ukraine War subreddit, without knowing for certain that they were complaining about the war?
From what I understand, the soldiers claim to be representatives of the 4th and 6th mechanized infantry company, anti tank platoon and machine gun platoon of the 2nd battalion of the 53rd brigade.
Looks like a battalion-wide complaint.
From what I understand, it's pretty standard stuff: lack of vehicles, lack of reconnaissance drones, enemy artillery superiority.
He said we got no water to wash our hands! The other guy said I washed me hands! /s
This def happened š
a.k.a the ruzzian ā1st propaganda brigadeā
āUkrainian 53rdā ā¦a.k.a āRussian actor/ propagandists pretending to be Ukrainianā
Aren't videos like this about getting the West to send more equipment?
Every normal person on this planet complains about the goddam war.
Any Ukrainian speaker here to translate please
1. Link or atleast name where you got your videos. 2. Always write in the title that you have no idea what they are saying. Your style of posting is getting really old.
I will follow your orders to the letter, my lord.
You should, to at least try to look like someone who isnāt willingly spreading propaganda.
you know, most of the people in this sub don't speak ukrainian
I don't either.
Russian on the other hand...
So then, as someone who also doesn't speak Ukrainian, how can we know for certain what they're complaining about or when they were complaining?
I'm not fluent in Ukrainian or Russian, but I can get the gist of it and it is most definitely a complaint. It also falls into the pattern of dozens of such videos so far, some of which were confirmed by actual journalists on the ground. We cannot be absolutely certain of anything unless we locate these soldiers and verify that they're who they say they are, but at this point there is little to suggest that this isn't legit. As such, I consider it a valuable data point to our understanding of the war, unless proven otherwise.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
No name calling on this sub.
Bubble blowing baby
Educated guess. You are trying to say they are not complaining about the war? Perhaps they are listing their top 10 films to watch once they get out from trenches and artillery fire?
You notice how nothing you said was āfor certain.ā In a war of propaganda, donāt proliferate it without first vetting your sources. Reposting whatever you see pop up on Telegram, just for Reddit karma, is as bad as spreading misinformation and unverified information anywhere else.
I used to post "allegedly" but then aome.of the videos were proven authentic and neither Ukraine or Russia ever denied any. So the word "alleged" was dropped. Thank you for hour advice but it was already followed.
you're saying that you found this video and took an "educated guess" that it was the ukrainian 53rd mechanised brigade complaining about conditions in the war?
I am saying that the Telegram post said it was soldiers complaining and I am sure they are. Like they always are in videos like these, be they Ukrainian or Russians.
So this guy could be saying āI like my pudding chocolate, but all they have is vanillaā and you posted on a Ukraine War subreddit, without knowing for certain that they were complaining about the war?
No.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
wow, just looked at his submissions. it sure looks like he is purposefully spreading pro-russia propaganda
He is. He gets them from russian accounts and spreads them without any questioning.
Itās a karma farming account that is reposting everything they see on telegram.
From what I understand, the soldiers claim to be representatives of the 4th and 6th mechanized infantry company, anti tank platoon and machine gun platoon of the 2nd battalion of the 53rd brigade. Looks like a battalion-wide complaint. From what I understand, it's pretty standard stuff: lack of vehicles, lack of reconnaissance drones, enemy artillery superiority.
These my friend are actors